Monday, May 14, 2007

John McCain - Need answers!

Need answers from Senator McCain.
Mike Ghouse, May 14, 2007

Tim Russet is one of my favorite journalists, he digs, he asks the right questions and gives the room to the inteviewee to respond, and does not harass them if they are lying, but leaves them alone and lets people make their own judgment.
A few excerpts from the interview with Russett and a few questions for the Senator;

SEN. McCAIN: ".....The president, the president has vetoed, and we continue to, to try to micromanage this war, and, and if you want us out of there, then cut off the funding and bring them home tomorrow."

Senator, what are you saying? Are you really ready to bring our men and women home tomorrow? It seems you are not comfortable iniating it due to party loyalty, but would welcome it via cutting off the funds. Are you suggesting congress to take that step? So you remain politically safe? What is important to you sir, country or party? Your patriotism is sterling, but what about your politics? Are you compromising? Would you be on that path if you were elected?

SEN. McCAIN: "Yes, and these same intelligence agencies gave us some very bad intelligence about four years ago, as well, as you might--as you might recall. But the fact, the fact is, this is long, hard difficult."

How do we trust the new information, it is based on the old information which you thrash.

SEN. McCAIN: "Sure I do. Americans are frustrated and saddened by the enormous sacrifice we've made and the gross mismanagement of the war. "

Senator, you supported the war from the beginnning, what has stopped you from speaking up, why did you not fix the problem? Your willingness to go along worries me about our future.

SEN. McCAIN: "Look, I think, I think by the end of this year we will see some signs of success, how significant those will be. But if every Republican is against it, if every Republican calls for withdrawal, I will do what my conscience, my knowledge, my--I know what war is. I know how evil these people are. "

Senator your are not sure about it, you were hoping to get the nominations by then. Leadership requires taking the lead and getting every Republican to see your point of view, not the other way around.

MR. RUSSERT: "In 2000 you lost the Republican nomination to George Bush. Would it be ironic that you lost the 2000 nomination because you embraced George Bush's Iraq war policy? "

SEN. McCAIN: "Life isn't fair. I did not embrace the policy for a number of years. I was one of the severest critics. But life isn't fair. But I--I've had a wonderful opportunity to serve this country. I have been the--I am the luckiest guy you will ever have on this program. I've been honored to serve. And I will continue to serve in some capacity until I am unable to do so. "

Senator, you seem like a helpless victim " Life isn't fair.." Sir, I do not accept this answer from you. Though wrong, President Bush wasn't wishy washy, you are not only wrong, but sound wishy washy as well.

The full transcript and the video is avaialble.

Your comments are certainly welcome.

javascript:msnvDwd '00','393219d9-4bb8-486e-8e33-6e89a8b43a86','us','hotvideo_m_edpicks','c2596','msnbc','','18641266','Sen.%20McCain\u2018s%20mother,%2095%20years%20youn'

Mike Ghouse is a Speaker, Thinker, Writer and a Moderator. He is president of the Foundation for Pluralism and is a frequent guest on talk radio, discussing interfaith, political and civic issues. He founded the World Muslim Congress with a simple theme: "good for Muslims and good for the world." His personal Website is www.MikeGhouse.net and his articles can be found on the Websites mentioned above and in his blogs: http://MikeGhouseforAmerica.Blogspot.com and http://MikeGhouse.Sulekha.com . He can be reached at MikeGhouse@gmail.com. Mike lives in Carrollton with his family and has been a Dallasite since 1980.
# # # # # # #
---------------------------------------------------------------------

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/18573163/


John McCain on Meet the Press, Sunday, May 13, 2007
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/18573163/

Meet the Press’ transcript for May 13, 2007
Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) discusses his 2008 presidential bid
getCSS("3053751")
Meet the Press on your schedule

‘Meet the Press’ transcript for May 13, 2007
Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) discusses his 2008 presidential bid

MR. TIM RUSSERT: Our issues this Sunday: Our Meet the Candidates 2008 series continues, an exclusive interview with Republican John McCain. He represented Arizona in the U.S. House for four years, for the past twenty years in the U.S. Senate where he now serves as the ranking member on the Armed Services Committee. He ran unsuccessfully for the Republican nomination for president in 2000. This morning John McCain joins us for the full hour on MEET THE PRESS.

Senator McCain, welcome back to MEET THE PRESS.

SEN. JOHN McCAIN (R-AZ): You didn't have to say unsuccessful; everybody knows that.

MR. RUSSERT: Well, all part of the history. Let's go right to it--Iraq.

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: We've been talking to voters across the country, our NBC/Wall Street Journal poll: Is victory in Iraq still possible? Thirty-six percent say victory's possible; 55 percent say victory not possible. And look at this, senator. Was the war--was the war--was it a mistake to send troops? Fifty- eight percent say yes, a mistake; 40 percent say no. Are you surprised at those numbers?

SEN. McCAIN: Not too. Particularly on the issue of the second question, when we have experienced the enormous difficulties and sacrifice that have been part of this conflict that, certainly, you can understand that. Americans are frustrated, and they're saddened our failures in this conflict. My point is, and I'm sure we'll get into it, and that is we have a chance of success, and I don't think that a lot of Americans are as fully aware as they should be of the consequences of failure in Iraq.

MR. RUSSERT: When you were speaking in 2005, the American Enterprise Institute, you said this...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: "If we can't retain the support of the American people, we will have lost this war as soundly as if our forces were defeated on the battlefield." Haven't they lost the support of the American people?

SEN. McCAIN: I think if we can show the American people some successes in Iraq and continue and expand on some of the successes we've already experienced in Anbar province and some neighborhoods in Baghdad, that I think Americans would--and if we do a better job, and that's people like me, of explaining the consequences of failure.

The consequences of failure, Tim, are that there would be chaos in the region. There's three--two million Sunni in Baghdad. The Iranians would continue to increase their influence, the Saudis would have to help the Sunni, the Kurds would want independence, the Turks will never stand for it. Some people say partition. You'd have to partition bedrooms in Baghdad because Sunni and Shia are, are married. This, this is a very, very difficult situation, but the consequences of failure, in my view, are unlike the Vietnam war where we could leave and come home and it was over, that these people will try to follow us home and the region will erupt to a point where we may have to come back or we will be compating-- combating what is now, to a large degree, al-Qaeda, although certainly other--many other factors of sectarian violence, in the region.

MR. RUSSERT: In hindsight, was it a good idea to go into Iraq?

SEN. McCAIN: You know, in hindsight, if we had exploited the initial success, which was shock and awe, and we succeeded, and we had done the right things after that, all of us would be applauding what we did. We didn't. It was terribly mismanaged. It was--I went over there very shortly after the initial victory and came back convinced that we didn't have enough troops on the ground, we were making the wrong decisions, and that Secretary Rumsfeld was badly mismanaging the conflict. And I spoke about it and complained for years. So, if we had succeeded and done the right thing after the initial military success, then all of us would be very happy that one of the most terrible, cruel dictators in history was removed from power. Now, because of our failures, obviously we have paid a very heavy price in American blood and treasure and a great sacrifice.

MR. RUSSERT: So it was a good idea to go in?

SEN. McCAIN: I think at the time, given the information we had. Every intelligence agency in the world, not just U.S., believed that Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction. He had acquired and used them before. There was no doubt that he was going to acquire and use them if he could. The sanctions were breaking down. The Oil for Food scandal was in the billions of dollars. And, of course, at the time, given the information we had--hindsight is 20/20. If we'd have known we were going to experience the failures we experienced, obviously it would give us all pause. Yet the information and the knowledge and the situation at the time, I think that it was certainly justified.

MR. RUSSERT: The Pentagon's Quarterly Report, the director of the CIA, the director of the Defense Intelligence Agency, all have said that sectarian violence is the problem. In fact, the--General Maples said that al-Qaeda accounts for only a small fraction of the insurgent violence.

SEN. McCAIN: You know the...

MR. RUSSERT: Who's our enemy?

SEN. McCAIN: Well, first of all, General Petraeus, the general on the ground, does not agree with that. Al-Qaeda is exploiting these sectarian differences. They are trying to orchestrate attacks on both Sunni and Shia, but--in order to spark this and increase this sectarian violence that's going on. Al-Qaeda is playing significantly. Now, are there problems with sectarian violence? Of course there is. Is there other problems, such as in Anbar Province where Sunnis are now combatting al-Qaeda? Are al-Qaeda being shoved out of Baghdad into areas outside of Baghdad? Yes. And are there problems in those areas?

Look, this is long and hard and difficult, and I've said it for a long time. And it's no last throes, it's no mission accomplished, it's no few dead-enders. It's long and hard and tough. We are experiencing some successes. Do we have to experience more? Yes. But to do what the Democrats want to do, and that's set a date for withdrawal, even those who opposed the war from the beginning don't think that that would lead to anything but an enormously challenging situation as a result.

MR. RUSSERT: But, senator, the Iraqi parliament, a majority of the Iraqi parliament, has signed a petition asking for a date certain for withdrawal of American troops. If the Iraqi parliament wants it, a majority in the Congress want it...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ...then why do you stand there and say, "No, you can't have it"?

SEN. McCAIN: Because it's my job to give my best estimate to the American people, no matter what the political calculations may be, as to what's the best in our nation's national security interest. Young men and women are risking their lives as we speak in, in, in Iraq. And I know that they will be in greater harm's way if we withdraw from Iraq, as we keep debating over and over and over again. And I know what's best, in my mind, in my experience, in my knowledge, in my inspiration, as to what's best for this country. So political calculations such as polls, I understand that if the American people don't continue to support this effort that we will be forced to withdraw. But it's also my obligation to tell the American people and my constituents in Arizona that I represent, what the consequences of failure will be; and I believe they will be catastrophic.

MR. RUSSERT: But the duly elected people's bodies, the U.S. Congress and the Iraqi parliament, say they want a troop withdrawal. That's more than a poll. Isn't that the voice of the people?

SEN. McCAIN: Well, the--as far as the Iraqi parliament is concerned, the Iraqi government obviously doesn't feel that way, their--the representatives in their government. Second of all, there is some, a certain amount of domestic political calculations involved there in what the Iraqi, quote, "parliament" said. The Iraqi parliament has their ability to, to voice their views, and I respect them. And I, as I say, I--I'll repeat again, I understand how democracies work. I saw it in Vietnam. I saw it in Vietnam. And I saw it in Vietnam, the predictions, that everything would be a worker's paradise in, in Vietnam if we left. And thousands were executed and millions went to re-education camps. So I, I believe that, that the consequences of failure, and particularly sitting on the large reserves of oil they have, particularly considering the influence of al-Qaeda is concerned, you will see enormous destabilization in the region, and that's my duty. That's my obligation. It's not my privilege. And political calculations should not enter into any information or position that I take on, on a, on an issue of national security.

MR. RUSSERT: The Iraqi parliament says they want to take a two-month vacation while our men and women shed their blood.

SEN. McCAIN: I am, I am unalterably opposed to it. One of the real difficulties we face in this conflict, obviously, is whether the Maliki government will act as an inclusive government, and whether the Maliki government will do the things that are necessary to be done. And I'm very concerned about it. All of us are very concerned about it. This government has to pass the oil revenue sharing law. This government has to pass de-Baathification. They have to declare elections in the provinces so that Sunni, who now want to take part in the electoral process, can have their representatives.

MR. RUSSERT: They've had four years to do this.

SEN. McCAIN: They have had this time, and they have done some things. It took us about 100 and some years before we had a bloody civil war to decide the future of our country. This is a fledgling democracy. I'm not, I'm not making excuses for it, but they have not been in this business before. And yet that does not change the fact that, in my view, unless they act, it could jeopardize what is already in jeopardy.

MR. RUSSERT: Would you be in favor of a referendum amongst the Iraqi people to make a decision as to whether U.S. troops should stay or leave?

SEN. McCAIN: No, no more than I should--would have a referendum in the United States of America as to whether Iraqi troops should leave, or whether we should be in or out of NATO, or any other issue. The Iraqi government is an elected government, and they are functioning. And so why we would need a, quote, "referendum" is no more necessary in this country as in that one. Does the Maliki government have to act more effectively, more inclusively? Absolutely they do, and it's of great concern, and I think it's one of the great vulnerabilities as we try to move forward and succeed there. Now, what's success? Economic, political and social progress, which can only be obtained in an environment of security. Neighborhoods in Baghdad are safer. They're not safe, but they are safer than they were before. And the government has to function more effectively, and then the Iraqi military and police take over those responsibilities as we gradually withdraw. That's the recipe for success.

MR. RUSSERT: The Iraqi army, over 120 battalions.

SEN. McCAIN: Yep.

MR. RUSSERT: There are only 10 battalions--10! That's 6,000 soldiers...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ...that are independently working separate and apart from Americans. How can it be, after four years, the Iraqis only have 6,000 soldiers operating independently?

SEN. McCAIN: Well, two things. One, because the war was so badly mismanaged. The--Secretary Rumsfeld claimed that there was, at one point, I believe, 175,000 trained, and they obviously fell apart. There's a difference, though, between those who can, can perform, quote, "independently," and those that can perform effectively alongside U.S. troops in Baghdad and around the country. There are--there are Iraqi units that still probably can't stand up on their own, but they can operate effectively alongside U.S. military. The key to it is, will we be able to train more who can operate independently on their own? We have a ways to go. But we, again, with this new strategy--and it is a strategy, not a surge--we have been able to see significant improvement. Enough improvement? Probably not. But at least we're seeing some progress. And our commanders on the ground are saying that the Iraqi military is functioning far more effectively, effective, and we are seeing progress there.

MR. RUSSERT: Jim Miklaszewski, our Pentagon correspondent, reports that he's being told by senior military officials that, come April, we do not have the troops to continue to send to Iraq in the rotation that we've been--that's been ongoing. We simply don't have them.

SEN. McCAIN: Come next April.

MR. RUSSERT: That's correct.

SEN. McCAIN: We are increasing the size of the Army and Marine Corps. Another one of the great failings when we began this was not increasing the size of the Army and Marine Corps. I've said for years that we need to dramatically increase them, particularly in certain specialties. I hope that the increased recruitment that we are experiencing now will give us an opportunity to increase those numbers. I also hope that we can see some signs of success in this challenge that we are facing.

MR. RUSSERT: General Petraeus said this: "Any student of history recognizes there's no military solution to a problem like that in Iraq, to the insurgency of Iraq."

SEN. McCAIN: And, you know, I've had many conversations with General Petraeus and I don't want to put words in his mouth, but he'll also tell you that history shows us, any student of history will tell, you that in--if--unless you have an environment of security for the people to try to live normal lives, and the economic, politically--political and social environment is able to grow and flourish, then you are doomed to failure. So, when you say it's all we--it's all up to the Iraqis, that's like saying a neighborhood that's been taken over by gangs, it's up to the people in the neighborhood. We have to do whatever we can to provide them with an environment in which they can exist and begin to lead normal lives. We are showing some success. The, the strategy before was, "Go kill people." It was the old search-and-destroy. "Go kill people and go back to your base." We've now got 53 or more outposts in Baghdad where Iraqi and American military are 24/7. There are some progress being made, and General Petraeus will say that, too. Enough? We'll see.

MR. RUSSERT: It's been more than four years.

SEN. McCAIN: I know.

MR. RUSSERT: And the American people are saying, "Why are we shedding our blood, and they're taking vacations as a parliament?" They don't have independent soldiers and battalions up and running. Our "National Intelligence Estimate" "outlines increasingly perilous situation in which the United States has little control" "strong possibility of further deterioration, according to sources familiar with the document.

"It couches glimmers of optimism in deep uncertainty about whether the Iraqi leaders will be able to transcend sectarian interests," "fight against extremists, establish effective national institutions and end rampant corruption."

That's our own intelligence agency...

SEN. McCAIN: Yes.

MR. RUSSERT: ...four years out.

SEN. McCAIN: Yes, and these same intelligence agencies gave us some very bad intelligence about four years ago, as well, as you might--as you might recall. But the fact, the fact is, this is long, hard difficult. And we talk about these present challenges that we face. We don't talk a lot about what happens if we fail, and I think that that's got to be part of any national discussion that we have. And the consequences of failure are chaos, genocide and, when you--when--and I'm sure you will ask this at some point, what's plan B? My, my, my question to those who say, "Let's set a date for withdrawal," what's your plan B? And the fact is, if we spent time on plan A, we, we, and give it a chance to succeed, I think would be a useful way of spending our time.

MR. RUSSERT: But under your plan, you're strongly suggesting we're going to be there for the next 10 years at least in order to secure and stabilize that country.

SEN. McCAIN: I am suggesting that we will have--hopefully reach a situation where American troops will not be on the front lines, where--and, by the way, that will not be immediately--where American troops are able to withdraw. We've had troops in South Korea for 60 years, and Americans are, are very satisfied with that situation. The key to it is, is the Iraqi military and police taking over these responsibilities. And that is, I believe, the ultimate way we're going to know whether we can reduce American casualties and they take over the responsibilities for, for governing their own country and militarily attacking and resisting al-Qaeda and other sectarian violence which will be there for a long, long time.

MR. RUSSERT: And we're going to be there for a long time.

SEN. McCAIN: But if it is--if it is--if it is only in a role that is of support and American casualties are minimal, then I think it's probably worth the investment. If the level of casualties stays where it is and we do not have success, then we know that that will be a, a condition that we cannot stand for.

MR. RUSSERT: By when?

SEN. McCAIN: I don't have a date. I think that the important thing is whether we assess as we move along. Everybody talks about--some people talk about April or May--August. Some people talk about September. The fact is that we've got to be showing progress along the way, and we will be--have plenty of time to assess that.

Look, Tim, I understand you, you are voicing the frustration that Americans feel. We've only got four of the five brigades over there now. We have just begun this new strategy. It is barely beginning, and I think it ought to be given a chance to succeed or fail. And for us to, to go for two months of funding after we voted time and time again. The president, the president has vetoed, and we continue to, to try to micromanage this war, and, and if you want us out of there, then cut off the funding and bring them home tomorrow.

MR. RUSSERT: Let me show you the kinds of things that are often said when soldiers are overseas, like this: "There's no reason for the United States to remain. The American people want them home. I believe the majority of Congress wants them home. Our continued military presence allows another situation to rise, which could then lead to the wounding, killing or capture of American fighting men and women. We should do all in our power to avoid that. What should be the criteria is our immediate, orderly withdrawal. And if we do not do that and other Americans die then I" "say that the responsibilities for that lie with the Congress who did not exercise their authority under the Constitution. For us to get into nation-building, law and order, etc., I think, is a tragic and terrible mistake."

You hear those kinds of words, right?

SEN. McCAIN: Sure I do. Americans are frustrated and saddened by the enormous sacrifice we've made and the gross mismanagement of the war. Now, my response to that statement is and what happens after we leave? Listen to all of the experts who will tell you that we can have a situation in the region which will, in, in the long run, entail far greater casualties, far greater dislocation, far greater threats to our national security than trying to give this an opportunity to succeed. That's what the--my response to that heartfelt statement is.

MR. RUSSERT: Well, those are your words from 1993 about Somalia.

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: And that's the kind of thing we're hearing about Iraq.

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: You felt that way about Somalia when you saw no end in sight.

SEN. McCAIN: Yes, I did, and...

MR. RUSSERT: And many Americans now are echoing your words about Iraq, because they see no end in sight.

SEN. McCAIN: Well, if you compare--want to compare Somalia to what's at stake in Iraq, please feel free to do so. I don't see any comparison except that there was chaos in the streets of Mogadishu, and this now is got to do with vital national security interests. I also said that we should get out of Beirut when we did, because a, a presence of a few Marines in a barracks was not going to, in any way, significantly impact what was going on in Lebanon. And I was right, and a lot of young Marines died because we--of the way that we put a presence in there without any chance of success.

MR. RUSSERT: You say we're making progress. You've been on this program talking about Iraq. In 2003...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ...you said, "I believe we've achieved significant goals"; 2005, we view it as, as "hopeful," we're making "progress"; 2006, we're on the "right track," "I want to emphasize again" the "good things happening"; we're "showing signs of success" in 2007. It's upbeat, upbeat, upbeat.

SEN. McCAIN: I think...

MR. RUSSERT: And yet the reality is quite different than that kind of optimistic message.

SEN. McCAIN: You know, Tim, I think it would be fair also to put the statements that I made when I came back from Iraq that said it was a failed policy, that we had to have more troops on the ground, that we were not carrying out the right kind of effort at training and equipping the Iraqis, that the Iraqi government wasn't--so it might be fair to flash some of those statements up, including the long speech I gave, after I came back from Iraq, to the Council on Foreign Relations, where I said if we pursue this failed policy, we will fail in Iraq. So I think that that might balance it out a bit. Do I think we had, we had made some progress? Yes. And do I think that we have had some significant setbacks? Yes. We-- both is--are the case.

MR. RUSSERT: You made a lot of news back in April when you went to Iraq. You went on a radio show and said never--had a news conference, "never been able to go out in the city as I was today." And then later these photographs were released, where we saw--(clears throat) excuse me--John McCain in the marketplace, surrounded, wearing a flack jacket. The next day the papers said that, "A day after members of an American congressional delegation led by Senator John McCain pointed to their brief visit" in "Baghdad's central Market as evidence that the new security plan for the city was working, the merchants were incredulous about" "Americans' conclusions. `What are they talking about?'" "the owner of an electrical supply shop said. `The security procedures were abnormal.' The delegation arrived at the market" "more than 100 soldiers in armored humvees--the equivalent of an entire company," "attack helicopters circled overhead, a senior" "military official in Baghdad said. The soldiers redirected traffic from the area" "restricted access to the American." "The congressmen wore bulletproof vests" through the hour-long visit. `They paralyzed the market when they came,'" "`This was only for the media.'"

SEN. McCAIN: Well, I don't...

MR. RUSSERT: Wasn't that...

SEN. McCAIN: ...I don't know who Mr. Faiyad is, and I'm sorry that I didn't see him. I talked with many, many of the merchants. We stayed there for more, more than an hour. That same place was not a functioning market a short time before. A bomb had gone off in that area and killed many, many people. There, there was a group of people that I talked to, as I traveled--walked around that, that shopping area for over an hour who said, "I'm glad to see you. Things are better." They--some--a guy came and complained about a sniper that, that they'd had problems with, and the police chief we talked to about that.

My point is the neighborhoods are safer. They are not safe. That's why we have to continue what we're doing. We have a new strategy that, that can succeed. I was glad to walk through that market. I will go walk through a market as often as I can. It was not allowed to go through a market a short time before that.

MR. RUSSERT: But, senator, you had an armed escort.

SEN. McCAIN: I had an armed escort because, because that's what General Petraeus thought we ought to have. I was glad to go outside of Baghdad and have over an hour opportunity to talk to the people that I talked to. Now, they are very different from the people that, that you are quoting here and others. They said, "I'm glad to see you. Things are better here. We have, we have seen improvement." That's what I was told, and that's what the other two members of Congress were told when we were there. You can find a lot of difference of opinion if you want to, but I believe that it's important for me to go out and meet those people if I can and be around them. I didn't call for the kind of, quote, "protection" that was around me. But I am not afraid, and I'm glad to go any place that I can to talk to the people of Iraq and tell them of my commitment to see that they have a free, democratic government where they don't have to face the bombs going off and the suicide bombers and the--and can start leading normal lives. And I'll do that every chance I get.

MR. RUSSERT: But the military felt you needed that protection, and the number of suicide bombers has gone up since the surge began.

SEN. McCAIN: The military--the suicide bombers have gone up because they know that this is probably the most effective way publicitywise. It's not the most effective way if you're talking about winning a conflict. Suicide bombers are the most difficult of any to counter, people who are willing to take their own lives in order to take others'. You can ask the Israelis; I think they'll tell you that. They have literally sealed their borders, and yet suicide bombers get across. And again, is this long and hard and difficult? Is that market safe? No, but it's safer than it was before. And that, in my view, is the key to whether we will succeed or fail or not. And I'll be glad to go back to that market with or without military protection and, and humvees, etc. But the fact is, I walked through narrow streets. I didn't have people all around me. I don't know what, what--where they get their information, but I was glad to walk around and talk to people and have contact with them and tell them that I, as an American, will do everything I can to let them lead the normal lives which are God-given rights to everybody on earth.

MR. RUSSERT: There seems to be a real erosion in support of the war amongst Republicans.

SEN. McCAIN: Yeah.

MR. RUSSERT: Eleven Republican congressmen met with the president. One said "My district is prepared for defeat if that's what you are going to say, Mr. President."

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: The leader of the Republicans in the Senate, Mitch McConnell, "condemned the Iraqi government for its failure to resolve security and political problems more expeditiously and predicted that, unless the current troop surge succeeds, U.S. policy will be changed by year's end either by" the president or by "congressional action."

SEN. McCAIN: Well, first of all, I share his, his dismay, and we've discussed it already about the Iraqi government's failure to act effectively. When I was over there, I met with Iraqi government officials and told them how important it is for them to act as a inclusive government, and, and I believe that they certainly are having messages sent. I hope that they are receiving them. And again, I understand the lack of patience on the part of the American people. And we're getting a little circular here in how sad and, and frustrated they are.

MR. RUSSERT: But these are the Republicans. They're, they're--Mitch McConnell's saying that they're ready to move this year, Republicans in Congress, against the war unless the surge shows success relatively quickly.

SEN. McCAIN: Look, I think, I think by the end of this year we will see some signs of success, how significant those will be. But if every Republican is against it, if every Republican calls for withdrawal, I will do what my conscience, my knowledge, my--I know what war is. I know how evil these people are. I know what war, war and peace is about. And I know the consequences, from my study of history and knowledge and background, the consequences of failure. So if I'm the last man standing, I have an obligation to do what my conscience and my knowledge and my background and everything I've known through my well-experienced life is best for this country. And I will not change from that, from that position. But I also understand what public opinion does and what democracies do. But that doesn't mean that I change my views and my positions and blowing in the, in the direction of which the political winds are blowing.

MR. RUSSERT: In 2000 you lost the Republican nomination to George Bush. Would it be ironic that you lost the 2000 nomination because you embraced George Bush's Iraq war policy?

SEN. McCAIN: Life isn't fair. I did not embrace the policy for a number of years. I was one of the severest critics. But life isn't fair. But I--I've had a wonderful opportunity to serve this country. I have been the--I am the luckiest guy you will ever have on this program. I've been honored to serve. And I will continue to serve in some capacity until I am unable to do so.


MR. RUSSERT: We're going to take a quick break. We're going to come back and talk to John McCain about other issues--immigration, taxes and more--right after this.

(Announcements)

MR. RUSSERT: More Meet the Candidates 2008. We're with Republican candidate John McCain, after this station break.

(Announcements)

MR. RUSSERT: We're back. The Republican candidate for president John McCain.

Immigration reform, a signature issue for you. Here's how The Washington Post reported it. "The co- author of lat year's immigration bill" "John McCain, has been largely absent from this year's negotiations, as he soft-pedals his pro-immigration stance.

"Senate Majority Whip Dick Durbin" of Illinois "said McCain's absence from the negotiations has been a big factor in the rising tide of Republican opposition" to the bill.

SEN. McCAIN: Actually, as short a time ago as Friday, I was in a meeting with Senator Graham and Senator Kennedy. I've been on many meetings. I'm on constant contact on this issue. I think we are close to an agreement that I think can pass both Houses, the Senate this time. The president's been heavily engaged, Secretary Chertoff has been heavily engaged. And Secretary Gutierrez, other Republicans, including my friend John Kyl has done a tremendous job in this effort, and I think we've close to an agreement that we can bring to the floor. And I've been heavily engaged in daily having conversations with people on all sides of this issue.

MR. RUSSERT: The New York Times says McCain's aide says a--says his identification with Senator Kennedy has accounted for his political problems on the issues with conservatives.

SEN. McCAIN: I don't know who that aide might be. The fact is...

MR. RUSSERT: Would you be willing to tell...

SEN. McCAIN: Could I just respond? I--I'm proud of the bipartisan effort that I've made on many issues with Democrats and Republicans, ranging from Joe Lieberman on 9/11 to working on the other side of the aisle on immigration reform and others. And that's why I think I'm prepared to be president of the United States. The American people want us to work together on issues that are important to the American people. That's my record.

MR. RUSSERT: When you were in Iowa, you said you might be open to taking illegal immigrants who are here now and, rather than having a path to citizenship while they're here, rather, send them back to their home country.

SEN. McCAIN: No, what I've said is it's one of the proposals that's on the table. We want to consider everything. If someone just came here yesterday, they should be sent back. We are looking on a--at a package, a comprehensive approach. We are in agreement, no matter where we stand on the--on the specifics of this issue, that doing nothing, the status quo, is totally unacceptable with broken borders and with 12 million people in America illegally. We have to assure the American people, whether they be Democrat or Republican, that we will secure the borders. I believe it has to be comprehensive. But I also understand very well that securing the border first and then taking the necessary steps on a temporary worker program and addressing the 12 million people is the way we have to go. And there is certainly an agreement on those principles amongst most members.

MR. RUSSERT: You think you're going to get a deal.

SEN. McCAIN: I think we're very close to it, and, and I'm very pleased to see that we have a number of the more conservative Republicans engaged in, in this effort, as well as people on the other side of the aisle. And I'm especially glad the president has been actively engaged. He can--he understands this issue as well as anyone, having been governor of the state of Texas.

MR. RUSSERT: On tax cuts. You were on this program back in '03, and I asked you this...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ..."Do you believe the president, because of the war, should be asking Americans for more sacrifice," "should" not "hold off any future tax cuts"--"should hold off" "any future tax cuts until we have a sense of the costs of the war and the state of our economy?"

"Yes, I do. I believe that until we find out the costs of this war and the reconstruction that we should hold off..."

SEN. McCAIN: Could I just respond? I--I'm proud of the bipartisan effort that I've made on many issues with Democrats and Republicans, ranging from Joe Lieberman on 9/11 to working on the other side of the aisle on immigration reform and others. And that's why I think I'm prepared to be president of the United States. The American people want us to work together on issues that are important to the American people. That's my record.

MR. RUSSERT: When you were in Iowa, you said you might be open to taking illegal immigrants who are here now and, rather than having a path to citizenship while they're here, rather, send them back to their home country.

SEN. McCAIN: No, what I've said is it's one of the proposals that's on the table. We want to consider everything. If someone just came here yesterday, they should be sent back. We are looking on a--at a package, a comprehensive approach. We are in agreement, no matter where we stand on the--on the specifics of this issue, that doing nothing, the status quo, is totally unacceptable with broken borders and with 12 million people in America illegally. We have to assure the American people, whether they be Democrat or Republican, that we will secure the borders. I believe it has to be comprehensive. But I also understand very well that securing the border first and then taking the necessary steps on a temporary worker program and addressing the 12 million people is the way we have to go. And there is certainly an agreement on those principles amongst most members.

MR. RUSSERT: You think you're going to get a deal.

SEN. McCAIN: I think we're very close to it, and, and I'm very pleased to see that we have a number of the more conservative Republicans engaged in, in this effort, as well as people on the other side of the aisle. And I'm especially glad the president has been actively engaged. He can--he understands this issue as well as anyone, having been governor of the state of Texas.

MR. RUSSERT: On tax cuts. You were on this program back in '03, and I asked you this...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ..."Do you believe the president, because of the war, should be asking Americans for more sacrifice," "should" not "hold off any future tax cuts"--"should hold off" "any future tax cuts until we have a sense of the costs of the war and the state of our economy?"

"Yes, I do. I believe that until we find out the costs of this war and the reconstruction that we should hold off..."

SEN. McCAIN: Could I just respond? I--I'm proud of the bipartisan effort that I've made on many issues with Democrats and Republicans, ranging from Joe Lieberman on 9/11 to working on the other side of the aisle on immigration reform and others. And that's why I think I'm prepared to be president of the United States. The American people want us to work together on issues that are important to the American people. That's my record.

MR. RUSSERT: When you were in Iowa, you said you might be open to taking illegal immigrants who are here now and, rather than having a path to citizenship while they're here, rather, send them back to their home country.

SEN. McCAIN: No, what I've said is it's one of the proposals that's on the table. We want to consider everything. If someone just came here yesterday, they should be sent back. We are looking on a--at a package, a comprehensive approach. We are in agreement, no matter where we stand on the--on the specifics of this issue, that doing nothing, the status quo, is totally unacceptable with broken borders and with 12 million people in America illegally. We have to assure the American people, whether they be Democrat or Republican, that we will secure the borders. I believe it has to be comprehensive. But I also understand very well that securing the border first and then taking the necessary steps on a temporary worker program and addressing the 12 million people is the way we have to go. And there is certainly an agreement on those principles amongst most members.

MR. RUSSERT: You think you're going to get a deal.

SEN. McCAIN: I think we're very close to it, and, and I'm very pleased to see that we have a number of the more conservative Republicans engaged in, in this effort, as well as people on the other side of the aisle. And I'm especially glad the president has been actively engaged. He can--he understands this issue as well as anyone, having been governor of the state of Texas.

MR. RUSSERT: On tax cuts. You were on this program back in '03, and I asked you this...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ..."Do you believe the president, because of the war, should be asking Americans for more sacrifice," "should" not "hold off any future tax cuts"--"should hold off" "any future tax cuts until we have a sense of the costs of the war and the state of our economy?"

"Yes, I do. I believe that until we find out the costs of this war and the reconstruction that we should hold off..."

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: "...on tax cuts."

You came back the next year, I again asked you about opposing the Bush tax cuts...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ...and this is what you said.

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

(Videotape, April 11, 2004)

SEN. McCAIN: I voted against the tax cuts because of the disproportional amount that went to the wealthiest Americans. I would clearly support not extending those tax cuts in order to help address the deficit.

(End videotape)

MR. RUSSERT: Disproportionate to the wealthiest Americans.

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: And you didn't--wouldn't extend them because it would hurt the deficit. You voted to extend them.

SEN. McCAIN: I voted to extend them because it would have the effect of having a tax increase. I also had a proposal, and also stated time after time, that we needed to restrain spending. The tax cuts have increased revenues enormously. I mean, they've been very beneficial. The problem is that spending has lurched completely out of control. My proposal was to restrain spending. And now, if you don't make them, those tax cuts, permanent, businesses, families, farms all over America will have to experience what, for all intents and purposes, the impact on them would be a tax increase. Would I have like to have seen more tax cuts to middle income Americans? Did I have a different proposal? Yes. But I supported tax cuts, and I have never supported--I have--I do not support tax increases. And the effect of not making them permanent would have the effect of a tax increase.

MR. RUSSERT: But, senator, there's a suggestion that, when you were running in 2000 and shortly thereafter...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ...you were this bold independent willing to stand up against tax cuts, even as a Republican.

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. I...

MR. RUSSERT: And saying they would increase the deficit. Then you decided, "Well, I got to become more of a traditional Republican," and you started embracing tax cuts.

SEN. McCAIN: Well, first of all, I had a tax cut proposal of my own which was very, very large and significant. So I didn't oppose tax cuts. And I'll show you that in my platform when I ran in 2000. So, I mean, that's just a fact, and I'll be glad to show it to you. Second thing is, I believe in tax cuts for Americans because I think it's important that...

MR. RUSSERT: Even during a war?

SEN. McCAIN: Even during a war. It is not--it is not the tax cuts that've caused us the fiscal difficulties we have. In fact, it has increased revenues. It is the spending which has completely lurched out of control, failure to reign in spending, having the government increase in size dramatically with unfunded liabilities. And that is the reason why we are facing the fiscal difficulties that we are today.

MR. RUSSERT: The spending on the war is considerable.

SEN. McCAIN: Spending on the war is considerable. Spending on an unfunded liability and a Medicare part D for 800 billion or a trillion dollars unfunded liability as well. Expanding the size of government as well. Failing to, to veto big spending bills such as a highway bill with $233 million bridge in Alaska to nowhere. Spending has got to be reigned in. Vetoes have got to be issued by the president of the United States. Earmarking has to stop, which not only increases spending but causes corruption in Washington, D.C.

MR. RUSSERT: But as you well know, you well know we keep defense spending, Social Security, Medicare and pensions at their same current rate...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ...you could veto every spending measure in all the rest of the government, close it all down, and you'd still have a deficit.

SEN. McCAIN: Sure, but how do you go to--hang--let me respond. How do you go to the American people and say we're going to have to make some tough decisions here on Social Security and Medicare if we're spending money on things that are frivolous and unnecessary? We've got to go to the American people with clean hands and say, "We've tightened our belt. We've reduced the size of government. We've stopped all this excess spending. We've stopped the pork barrel spending. Now let's sit down together, Republican and Democrat, like Ronald Reagan and Tip O'Neill did, and let's solve Social Security and Medicare rather than pass it on to an unluckier generation."

MR. RUSSERT: When I asked...

SEN. McCAIN: And that's what I intend to do as president of the United States, and I am prepared to do.

MR. RUSSERT: When I asked you about that in 2005--February 20th on this show...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ...I said one of the suggestions is that the payroll tax, which is now capped at $90,000 of income...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ...be lifted so the people who pay a payroll tax on more than the first 90,000.

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: You said you'd be willing to do that as part of a compromise.

SEN. McCAIN: I am...

MR. RUSSERT: Is that still your view?

SEN. McCAIN: The president of the United States has said everything on the table. I am against tax increases, and that's a well-known position of mine. But I think that, as the president has said, he'll sit down with everything on the table. Am I opposed to tax increases? Yes. But we've got to sit down together and figure out what our options are, and tough decisions have to be made, Republicans and Democrats. And I know how to do that. That's been my experience in the--as a United States senator, reaching across the aisle, addressing the tough issues in a bipartisan fashion where bipartisanship is called for.

MR. RUSSERT: Rudy Giuliani, the mayor of New York, your opponent for the Republican nomination, said the other day that he's pro-choice, pro-abortion rights.

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: Can someone who is pro-choice, pro-abortion rights be nominated by the Republican Party?

SEN. McCAIN: I don't know the answer to that, but I know that the base of our party--and I have been pro-life unchanging and unwavering for all of my political career, and I think that an important part of the base of our party is a pro-life position. But I, I--we'll, as Chris Berman says, that's why they play the game.

MR. RUSSERT: Could you support a nominee who was pro-abortion rights?

SEN. McCAIN: I can support a nominee if it's a nominee of the party, if--no matter what their position are. But I would not agree with that position.

MR. RUSSERT: Back in 1999, you gave an interview to the San Francisco Chronicle, and you said this...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ..."Certainly in the short term, or even the long term, I would not support repeal of Roe vs. Wade, which would then force X number of women in American to undergo illegal and dangerous operations."

SEN. McCAIN: Well, it was in the context of conversation about having to change the culture of, of America as regards to this issue. That is a conversation that I had in that context. I have stated time after time after time that Roe v. Wade was a bad decision, that I support a woman--the, the rights of the unborn. I have fought for human rights and human dignity throughout my entire political career. To me it is an issue of human rights and human dignity. That conversation was in the context of we have to help young women who are experiencing a crisis pregnancy. We have to help them with compassion, and we hope--have to help those young women with courage. And we also have to do whatever we can to let them know that if they don't want the child, if they'll bring them into life, that we'll do everything we can to help with adoption. Just like there's three--I have three adopted children. It's a wonderful thing. But my position has been consistently in my voting record, pro-life, and I continue to maintain that position and voting record. Is it a tough issue in America? Yes. But I believe the states should be making those decisions.

MR. RUSSERT: But if Roe vs. Wade was overturned in a--during a McCain presidency...

SEN. McCAIN: Yes.

MR. RUSSERT: ...and individual states chose to ban abortion...

SEN. McCAIN: Yes.

MR. RUSSERT: ...would you be concerned that, as you said, X number of women in America would undergo illegal and dangerous operations?

SEN. McCAIN: No, I would hope that X women in America would bring those, those children into birth and into life in this world, and that I could do whatever I could to assist them. Again, that conversation that you--that--from 1999, which is so often quoted, was in the context of my, my concerns about the issue, and the need to change the culture in America to understand the importance of the rights of the unborn. And I will continue to hold that view and position.

MR. RUSSERT: In 2000 you chose not to enter the Iowa caucuses.

SEN. McCAIN: Yep.

MR. RUSSERT: But this year you're going to enter the Iowa caucuses. And ethanol is a big issue in, in Iowa.

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: This is what you said about ethanol--not about subsidies, but about ethanol.

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: "Ethanol does nothing to reduce fuel consumption, nothing to increase our energy independence, nothing to improve air quality."

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: And after you said that, you acknowledged you might pay a political price for that view, and this is what you said.

(Videotape, June 19, 2005)

SEN. McCAIN: My opposition to ethanol has--obviously would hurt me. But you know what I found out? That every time I've done something from what may have been influenced by political reasons, I've regretted it. Every time that I've done something that I think is right, it's turned out OK in the end. I've got to do what I think is right. And if it offends a certain political constituency, I, I regret it, but there's really nothing I can do about it.

(End videotape)

MR. RUSSERT: Now you go to Iowa and say this: "I support ethanol. I think it's a vital alternative energy source, not only because of our dependence on foreign oil but because of its greenhouse gas reduction effects." You had said it had nothing to do with reducing fuel consumption, nothing to do with improving air quality.

SEN. McCAIN: I, I, I am of the confirmed belief that when oil is 10, $15 a barrel, that ethanol does not make sense. When oil is $60-plus a barrel, then ethanol does make sense. I still oppose the subsidies to it. It makes a lot of sense. We are dependent on foreign oil too much. We have a situation where greenhouse gases has now become--emissions has become a vital issue. I am for sugarcane, biofuels, switch grass, and corn-based ethanol because of our need for independence on foreign oil. And it has become far more graphic and dramatic as we watch people like Mr. Chavez in Venezuela behave the way that he has, and President Putin behaving the way that he does. It's a fact that when oil is low amounts per barrel and--that we are not concerned about greenhouse gases or dependence upon foreign oil, it doesn't make the sense that it makes today. It does make sense today.

MR. RUSSERT: But you do now disagree with what you said in '03, that it has nothing to do with reducing fuel consumption...

SEN. McCAIN: What I was...

MR. RUSSERT: ...or nothing to improve air quality?

SEN. McCAIN: I don't...

MR. RUSSERT: You now believe...

SEN. McCAIN: I don't know what--I don't know what it does to fuel consumption. I'm sure that there is some question about that, as the...

MR. RUSSERT: How about air quality?

SEN. McCAIN: ...as the, as the technology has increased dramatically. The air quality, it does reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Most effectively? Does--as much as nuclear power? No. But given our dependence on foreign oil, given the situation as the price of oil then--and, and the realities of climate change, we should go for many alternate fuels. I do not support the subsidies.

MR. RUSSERT: So you've changed your mind.

SEN. McCAIN: No, I haven't. I have--I have--I have adjusted to the realities of the world we live in today, and if I don't adjust to those realities, then I would be stuck in the past. I have to adjust to the realities. The realities today are that we have a serious problem with climate change, which I have been concerned about for many years, and we have a far more serious challenge as associated with our dependence on foreign oil.

Not too long ago, a year or so ago, there was an attempted attack on a Saudi oil refinery. If that attack had succeeded, the price of oil would have gone to $150 a barrel overnight.

MR. RUSSERT: And the reality of being part of the Iowa caucuses had nothing to do with it.

SEN. McCAIN: I don't--I don't--I can't respond to a, a statement like that.

MR. RUSSERT: But...

SEN. McCAIN: I do what I--I do what I think is right, and I will continue to do what I think is right. And if conditions change as far as some specific issue is concerned, then, obviously, then I will continue to re-evaluate my position on specific issues.

MR. RUSSERT: This...

SEN. McCAIN: My values, my principles, my goals, my ideals maintain exactly the same because they were formed long before I was running for any elected office.

MR. RUSSERT: The Senate on a voice vote in the--said that we should--in the committee...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ...increase miles per gallon for automobiles to 36 miles per gallon. You in favor of that?

SEN. McCAIN: I think we ought to increase the miles per gallon, but I think we ought to sit down with Detroit and see what they think is doable and come up with a consensus opinion.

MR. RUSSERT: Thirty-six too high?

SEN. McCAIN: Detroit--I don't--I don't--can't give a specific number, although I think we can sit down and find one that they think they can reach. The automobile industry in America is in very serious difficulties, as we know.

MR. RUSSERT: Before you go, interview with The Hill newspaper back in 2000 after your campaign didn't quite work out in 2000, and you were asked this: "Do you think you'll ever run for president again?"

"In 2004 I expect to be campaigning for the re-election of George Bush"--which you did.

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: "But by the year 2008 I believe my age would not equip me to run."

SEN. McCAIN: Well, you know, my energy level is great. My--I work 24/7. I'm pleased that I am in the excellent health, and I, I believe that I may not be the youngest candidate in this race, but I'm certainly the most prepared. And I'm prepared to lead this country. I don't need any on-the-job training. I'm ready to do the hard things, not the easy things. And that's what I intend to do.

MR. RUSSERT: On the day of your inauguration--this will not surprise you--for the first term of a president, John McCain...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ...January 20, 2009 would be 72 years...

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: ...four months, 22 days.

SEN. McCAIN: Mm-hmm.

MR. RUSSERT: Ronald Reagan on his first term inauguration, 69 years, 11 months, four days.

William Henry Harrison, 68 years, 23--several years older than Ronald Reagan.

SEN. McCAIN: And William Henry Harrison. The fact is that I'm in great shape, and I hiked the Grand Canyon with my son last August from rim to rim. I'm ready to serve, and I'm sure that people will make their own judgments. But they'll make their judgments by watching me and my performance. And they were very happy to see Ronald Reagan in for a second term.

MR. RUSSERT: And Wil--you were going to say about William Henry Harrison, after he took the oath...

SEN. McCAIN: Poor guy.

MR. RUSSERT: ...he died in a matter of months.

SEN. McCAIN: Poor guy. Yeah.

MR. RUSSERT: Senator John McCain, we have to leave it there.

SEN. McCAIN: Thanks.

MR. RUSSERT: Thank you for sharing your views.

SEN. McCAIN: Thank you.

MR. RUSSERT: And our viewers should know, as part of our Meet the Candidates 2008 series, we have invited all the major candidates for president to appear here for the full hour. We are also archiving the transcripts in videos of the entire series on our Web site, mtp.msnbc.com. Voters can review the candidates' positions throughout the entire campaign. And we'll be right back.

(Announcements)

MR. RUSSERT: That's all today. Before we go, kudos to major league baseball. Three hundred major league baseball players will be using these pink bats today to support the fight against breast cancer on Mother's Day. You can buy one of these special pink bats from Major League Baseball via the link on our Web site.

Happy Mother's Day to an in-studio guest, Mrs. Roberta McCain, John McCain's mom is here, and we're going to talk to her about her son and his behavior growing up. You can watch it on our Web site after the show.

And, of course, happy Mother's Day to all the great moms out there. We'll be back next week. If it's Sunday, it's MEET THE PRESS.

Sunday, May 13, 2007

Jerusalem for Capital?

Jerusalem for Capital?
Mike Ghouse, May 13, 2007
http://mikeghouseforamerica.blogspot.com/2007/05/jerusalem-for-capital-beware.html

My first response to this hook was; Yehud Olmert must be losing the support from the Israeli's really bad to have resorted to this.

People around the globe have different preferences, perhaps the number one priority for the Israelis is peace, so that they can go about living their daily life feeling secure. Moving the capital to Jerusalem is conceivably at the bottom of their list.

Vote for me, I will make (or work) Jerusalem, the capital of Israel. Yehud Olmert may find a similar song by his counterparts in India, it is the same tune; vote for us, we will build the Ram temple. It did not work for them, and I don't believe it will work for Olmert either.

The Indians may have wryly said to the BJP party in the last national elections 'go ahead and build the temple, you are the one's that need the blessings', but we will support those who can create jobs, keep the streets cleaner and facilitate potable water. The Israelis probably would put safety first.

All politicians who are on the losing edge use the same tactics. Beware of them.

Mike Ghouse
www.MikeGhouse.net

I just found these two pieces.... below to read.

http://www.abc.net.au/news/newsitems/200608/s1724411.htm

Most Israelis oppose Olmert: poll

A newspaper poll shows 63 per cent of Israelis want Prime Minister Ehud Olmert to resign, in a sharp public backlash over his handling of the war in Lebanon.

Israel's biggest circulation newspaper, the Yedioth Aronoth, calls the poll a political "earthquake" for the Olmert Government.

A career politician who lacks the combat credentials of many of his predecessors, Mr Olmert has seen his public standing decline sharply for failing to deliver a fatal blow to militant group Hezbollah, which is based in southern Lebanon and backed by Iran and Syria.

The Yedioth poll for the first time shows a majority wants Mr Olmert to step down.

In addition to calling for Mr Olmert's resignation, 74 per cent of respondents say Defence Minister Amir Peretz should go and 54 per cent want Army chief Dan Halutz to step down.

An August 16 poll published by Yedioth showed 41 per cent of Israelis wanted Mr Olmert to resign and 57 per cent wanted Mr Peretz to go.

At least 1,110 Lebanese people and 157 Israelis were killed in the conflict.

Aside from Israel's ongoing conflict with the Palestinians, Israel suffered heavier civilian casualties in the Lebanon conflict than in any fighting since the war at the creation of the Jewish state in 1948.

- Reuters

http://web.israelinsider.com/Articles/Politics/11290.htm
Polls: Most Israelis want Olmert to resign
By israelinsider staff May 2, 2007

Polls: Most Israelis want Olmert to resign
By israelinsider staff May 2, 2007


Bookmark to del.icio.usDigg This Story

A poll conducted by Haaretz-Dialog a day after the release of the Winograd report revealed that about 40 percent of the respondents are hoping Israel will hold new elections. Professor Camil Fuchs of Tel Aviv University's statistics department ran the poll.

According to a Yedioth Ahronoth poll conducted by the Dahaf Institute, 51 percent think new elections should be held, while 23 percent would like the leadership to change without elections.

The Haaretz poll found that between 10 and 17 percent of Israelis believe the current government should remain in office, but that Prime Minister Ehud Olmert should be replaced by Benjamin Netanyahu (Likud), Vice Premier Shimon Peres, or Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni.

Only nine percent of the Haaretz respondents and 10 percent of the Ynetnews respondents support the current government.

As far as public opinion on the Prime Minister, the Winograd report has not had a great impact on the public's views. Sixty-eight percent want Olmert to resign, a number which closely matches earlier polls that asked the same question. The Ynetnews poll had similar results, with 65 percent saying Olmert should resign.

Almost a quarter of those polled (23 percent) by Haaretz believe Olmert should stay in his post in order to fix his mistakes. The Ynetnews poll found that 27 percent think Olmert should be given a chance to correct his mistakes.

In Haaretz's regular bimonthly poll about how many Knesset each party should receive if elections were held now, Likud is in the lead with 30 seats. The Labor party follows with 21 seats.

Similarly, Benjamin Netanyahu is seen as the most suitable replacement for Prime Minister Olmert. On a scale of 1 to 10, Netanyahu leads with 5.27. Tzipi Livni follows in second place at 5.03, and Peres was rated 4.91 out of 10.

Netanyahu was also chosen as the person respondents would most like to have as prime minister with over a quarter (26 percent) choosing him, followed by Peres with 11 percent, Livni at 10 percent, and Barak and Olmert with only 6 percent each.

The Ynetnews poll also found Netanyahu is the favorite candidate to replace Olmert, with 29 percent. However, twice the percentage of those polled chose Livni (20 percent), 10 percent chose Ehud Barak. Olmert, as in the Haaretz poll, only received 6 percent.

Imperialism in 1857 & 2007

New Delhi in 1857 and Baghdad in 2007 - Imperialism then and now.

Mike Ghouse, May 13, 2007
http://mikeghouseforamerica.blogspot.com/2007/05/1857-imperialism-then-and-now.html

The following article about 1857 is worth reading. Jack Straw, the British foreign Secretary recently disclosed the atrocities the British Raj in India, including splitting the nation and creating long term strife. He was regretful of their past.

President Bush and Vice President Cheney are equally hallucinated, we may deny the concept of empire, but the imperialism beneath this war mongering and destruction is very apparent. They just cannot understand that they are responsible for the genocide of the Iraqis and that their bull headedness is apalling. The graceful thing to do is to bring our sons and daughters home. They can be wrong and be accountable to the lord, but we the Americans are the one's who have to bear the guilt of this genocide by the foursome; Cheney, Bush, Rice and Rumsfield and we don't.

Had we not gone to war, we would not have killed 650,000 + Iraqi lives, and 3500 of our own sons and daughters. We have wreaked havoc with the death and destruction of the Iraqi people and their infrastructure, and yet we blame their culture and religion for attacks and the sectarian violence. We have messed up the Iraqi people for at least two generations. It is a destructive war, we are wrong and we have to bring God in to our lives and be the humans Jesus and all the great teachers wanted us to be. Enough is enough.

The foursome owe an apology to Americans for lying and uploading the guilt of genocide on us, and to the Iraqi people for slaughtering their kith and kin. We went in for WMD, that was a lie, then we called it regime change, then we called ourselves liberators. Great job in fooling us, you can fool us a few times but not forever.

The British did not go to India to save the people; neither had they had the intent of staying and developing the nation, all they were interested in was shipping the raw materials back home, make products and sell it back. There was nothing wrong in doing business, but when it is un-fair, immoral and un-just, it does not survive. By God they were brutal monarchs, they did what they wanted to do, no rule of law, no morality, no accountability and no conscience.

The UK Foreign Secretary, Jack Straw, has blamed Britain's imperial past for many of the modern political problems, including the Arab-Israeli conflict and the Kashmir dispute. In an interview with a British magazine, the New Statesman, Mr Straw spoke of quite serious mistakes made, especially during the last decades of the empire.

He said the Balfour Declaration of 1917 - in which Britain pledged support for a Jewish homeland in Palestine - and the contradictory assurances given to Palestinians, were not entirely honourable. "The Balfour declaration and the contradictory assurances which were being given to Palestinians in private at the same time as they were being given to the Israelis - again, an interesting history for us, but not an honourable one," he said.

Mr Straw acknowledged "some quite serious mistakes" in India and Pakistan, jewels of the British empire before their 1947 independence, as well as Britain's "less than glorious role" in Afghanistan.

What about us? We are a democracy and we are letting our foursome make decisions in our behalf, our occupation is causing death and destruction. I beg our president not to wear that imperial hat, it does not fit him, he represents our will and not the imperial order.

History does not have to judge us, our conscience will, we have to answer to our kids and grand kids, what would we say to them? That we were chickens, and that we did not have guts to speak out and stop the massacre? And yet we are the nation that leads in humanitarian work, we are compassionate people yet shamelessly did not do anything about it. We have to answer ourselves

For God's sake, let's Speak out for your own sense of balance, at least we can tell the lord (or answer the conscience to mitigate the guilt) that we have done our part.


Mike Ghouse is a Speaker, Thinker, Writer and a Moderator. He is president of the Foundation for Pluralism and is a frequent guest on talk radio, discussing interfaith, political and civic issues. He founded the World Muslim Congress with a simple theme: "good for Muslims and good for the world." His personal Website is http://www.mikeghouse.net/ and his articles can be found on the Websites mentioned above and in his blogs: http://mikeghouseforamerica.blogspot.com/ and http://mikeghouse.sulekha.com/ . He can be reached at MikeGhouse@gmail.com. Mike lives in Carrollton with his family and has been a Dallasite since 1980.

Reference:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/2481371.stm
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/story/0,,2076320,00.html

Delhi, 1857: a bloody warning to today's imperial occupiers
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/story/0,,2076320,00.html

A century and a half after the Indian mutiny, echoes of the arrogance and lies that sparked insurgency could not be clearer

William Dalrymple
Thursday May 10, 2007
The Guardian

Soon after dawn on May 11 1857, 150 years ago this week, the Mughal Emperor Bahadur Shah Zafar was saying his morning prayers in his oratory overlooking the river Jumna when he saw a cloud of dust rising on the far side of the river. Minutes later, he was able to see its cause: 300 East India Company cavalrymen charging wildly towards his palace.

The troops had ridden overnight from Meerut, where they had turned their guns on their British officers, and had come to Delhi to ask the emperor to give his blessing to their mutiny. As a letter sent out by the rebels' leaders subsequently put it: "The English are people who overthrow all religions ... As the English are the common enemy of both [Hindus and Muslims, we] should unite in their slaughter ... By this alone will the lives and faiths of both be saved."

The sepoys entered Delhi, massacred every Christian man, woman and child they could find and declared the 82-year-old emperor to be their leader. Before long the insurgency had snowballed into the largest and bloodiest anticolonial revolt against any European empire in the 19th century. Of the 139,000 sepoys of the Bengal army, all but 7,796 turned against the British. In many places the sepoys were supported by a widespread civilian rebellion.

There is much about British imperial adventures in the east at this time, and the massive insurgency it provoked, which is uneasily familiar to us today. The British had been trading in India since the early 17th century. But the commercial relationship changed towards the end of the 18th, as a new group of conservatives came to power in London, determined to make Britain the sole global power. Lord Wellesley, the brother of the Duke of Wellington and governor general in India from 1798 to 1805, called his new approach the Forward Policy. But it was in effect a project for a new British century. Wellesley made it clear he would not tolerate any European rivals, especially the French, and planned to remove any hostile Muslim regimes that might presume to resist the west's growing might.

The Forward Policy soon developed an evangelical flavour. The new conservatives wished to impose not only British laws but also western values on India. The country would be not only ruled but redeemed. Local laws which offended Christian sensibilities were abrogated - the burning of widows, for instance, was banned. One of the East India Company directors, Charles Grant, spoke for many when he wrote of how he believed providence had brought the British to India for a higher purpose: "Is it not necessary to conclude that our Asiatic territories were given to us, not merely that we draw a profit from them, but that we might diffuse among their inhabitants, long sunk in darkness, the light of Truth?"

The British progressed from removing threatening Muslim rulers to annexing even the most pliant Islamic states. In February 1856 they marched into Avadh, also known by the British as Oudh. To support the annexation, a "dodgy dossier" was produced before parliament, so full of distortions and exaggerations that one British official who had been involved in the operation described the parliamentary blue book (or paper) on Oudh as "a fiction of official penmanship, [an] Oriental romance" that was refuted "by one simple and obstinate fact", that the conquered people of Avadh clearly "preferred the slandered regime" of the Nawab "to the grasping but rose-coloured government of the company".

The reaction to this came with the great mutiny, or as it is called in India, the first war of independence. Though it reflected many deeply held political and economic grievances, particularly the feeling that the heathen foreigners were interfering with a part of the world to which they were alien, the uprising was consistently articulated as a defensive action against the inroads missionaries and their ideas were making in India, combined with a generalised fight for freedom from western occupation.

Although the great majority of the sepoys were Hindus, there are many echoes of the Islamic insurgencies the US fights today in Iraq and Afghanistan. In Delhi a flag of jihad was raised in the principal mosque, and many of the resistance fighters described themselves as mujahideen or jihadis. There was even a regiment of "suicide ghazis" who vowed to fight until they met death.

Events reached a climax on September 14 1857, when British forces attacked the besieged city. They proceeded to massacre not only the rebel sepoys and jihadis, but also the ordinary citizens of the Mughal capital. In one neighbourhood alone, Kucha Chelan, 1,400 unarmed citizens were cut down. Delhi, a sophisticated city of half a million souls, was left an empty ruin.

The emperor was put on trial and charged, quite inaccurately, with being behind a Muslim conspiracy to subvert the empire stretching from Mecca and Iran to Delhi's Red Fort. Contrary to evidence that the uprising broke out first among the overwhelmingly Hindu sepoys, the prosecutor argued that "to Musalman intrigues and Mahommedan conspiracy we may mainly attribute the dreadful calamities of 1857". Like some of the ideas propelling recent adventures in the east, this was a ridiculous and bigoted oversimplification of a more complex reality. For, as today, western politicians found it easier to blame "Muslim fanaticism" for the bloodshed they had unleashed than to examine the effects of their own foreign policies. Western politicians were apt to cast their opponents in the role of "incarnate fiends", conflating armed resistance to invasion and occupation with "pure evil".

Yet the lessons of 1857 are very clear. No one likes people of a different faith conquering them, or force-feeding them improving ideas at the point of a bayonet. The British in 1857 discovered what the US and Israel are learning now, that nothing so easily radicalises a people against them, or so undermines the moderate aspect of Islam, as aggressive western intrusion in the east. The histories of Islamic fundamentalism and western imperialism have, after all, long been closely and dangerously intertwined. In a curious but very concrete way, the fundamentalists of all three Abrahamic faiths have always needed each other to reinforce each other's prejudices and hatreds. The venom of one provides the lifeblood of the others.

• William Dalrymple's The Last Mughal: The Fall of a Dynasty, Delhi 1857, has just been published in paperback by Bloomsbury
williamdalrymple.com

--------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------
Another comment relating to parallels between 1857 and Iraq/Afghanistan today.

In 1857, Britain was the de facto 'paramount power' in India (and generally the whole world.)The known world (or several known worlds) has/have had a paramount power since the Neolithic revolution c.10 thousand years ago. This, whatever bleeding-heart liberals, socialists, Third-Worldists, Christians and suchlike may think, is not going to change in the foreseeable future.

As the paramount power, Britain was under obligation to impose its vision of law, order and civilization on those under its 'yoke'. Having realized that many of the policies and practices of the 'Honourable East India Company's' rule had been incompetent and overly exploitative, the British government took India under its direct control in 1858, told Indians that they they would get law, order, civilization (as Britain saw it) and a degree of prosperity for themselves, BUT that, from now on, they would bl**dy-well do what they were told. That is the job of a paramount power. (Thank God Russia, France or Germany never attained that status.)
The British record in India from 1858 until Independence in 1947, was relatively benign and successful.

Yes there was the Amritsar massacre (British military stupidity conspiring with some Indians refusing do what they were bl**dy-well told), several horrific famines (British bureaucratic bungling and Indian superstitious primitivism making things worse) and, worst of all, the caving in to the Moslem fanatics over an independent Pakistan (hence 1947 massacres, Bagladesh War, Waziristan, Taleban, madrassas, 9/11, 7/7 etc. etc.) The great success was an India based on a secular ideology (now dying)and free of any REAL influence by 'naked fakir' primitivists such as Gandhi, whose intellectual ancestors had been defeated in 1857.
Today we have, God help us, as the world's paramount power, the United States of America !; a state based not primarily on enlightened self-interest but on a relgio-political ideology - 'Gahd-an'-Demahcracy'. So what do we get, after a perfectly legitimate attack on Afghanistan's Taleban (hosts of the 'Beardy Arab') and on the former client dictator Hussein (a real threat to the oil supply of the civilized world - forget the WOMD garbage)? What we get is a mad scheme to introduce democracy and humanitarian values into Moslem societies which, with their history and ideological underpinnings, have no possibility of adopting them.
As the British in 1857, the USA should have said/should now say to the Middle East, from Lebanon to the Indus is - 'We will give you order, law (as we see it, and it includes full equality of women)and (our) peace as well as a degree of prosperity. And from now on you will bl**dy-well do what you are told. End of message.
No hope of that of course, and we can only hope that the USA will soon decline ignominiously into second-rank power status, What abyss of oblivion awaits my native country (Britain), I shudder (and weep) to think of. The Moslems think they will be the next paramount power, with their Mohammedan 'caliphate'. Fat chance of that, praise be to All*h !

When China assumes its natural role as the world's 'central country', which we can only hope will be asap, we will have no nonsense of Western democracy, humanitarianism or religion. The greatest Chinese thinker, Lao Tze, established the basic principle of enlightened paramount power over two thousand years ago - 'Keep the stomachs of the people full and their minds empty.' and we can bet that they will apply it.

Presumably the Chinese will be too polite (and ethnocentric) to impose their order by overt aggression or insult but I, for one, would be delighted to receive their message in the following form - 'Now, you barbarians, br**dy-well do what told. Chop, chop!'

------------------------------ -------------------------------------------------- ------------------------

A few interesting comments;

Scrutator, “I was astonished at the insights Mr Dalrymple provided in his earlier book 'White Mughals', most particularly the recognition of Wellesley's fundamental role in promoting British exclusiveness, the 'stiff upper lip' and the belief that the Englishman was not like other people but had been chosen by God for a higher purpose.
I guess this new book will further his explication of what our forebears did in the sub-continent, for better or for worse. I shall look forward to reading it. My own research into the old English-language newspapers of Bombay etc suggests that everything the India Company did was consistently intelligible only in terms of profit. No wonder parliament required the destruction of the Company's commercial records.
I think it can reasonably be established that the Indian War of Independence commenced soon after Clive got the diwani of Bengal. Hyder Ali is an early exemplar and the Maratha attacks continued more or less continuously up to 1857. They were the people who might have governed India after the Mughal Raj had the English not intervened.
It has been a shock to see the India Company's tactics being repeated as western policy towards the rest of the world of late. The old phrase 'if you are not with us, you are against us' which a famous politician used recently, is a polite way of saying 'do as I say or I'll hit you'. Can we not do better than that?
What I particularly wish to thank Mr Dalrymple for is this percipient reminder that a people should know their history and understand the significance of it. If that message can be communicated to just one reader, this book will be completely worthwhile.’
------------ -----------
Dante, “Part of me hopes America continues to undermine its own dominance in this fashion, since this will probably lead to a fairer world more quickly, and part of me hopes for a more peaceful transition of power.”
---------- -----------
Grand Old Man, “One example i would give: The Mutinous sepoys- both hindu and Muslims- rushed to Delhi to proclaim the old Mughal "Emperor" to be their titular leader, not because he symbolised moderate islam, but because he was the ONLY crexdible candidate to be their titular leader- so i doubt that had anything to do with his religion.
There is also the use of emotive language- "Delhi, a sophisticated city of half a million, was left an empty ruin"- Implying all 500,000 inhabitants were ethnically cleansed.
Although there were no doubt many thousands of innocents murdered in the British revenge, I know of no reputable historian who would suggest the entire population were murdered or expelled.”
----- ----
Marksa- I'm no expert on Indian history, so I may be corrected on this: Both Suttee and Thugee DID exist in India and were punished and more or less eradicated by the Brits, but were almost certainly not as widespread as the Brits made out- because of course any incidents justified their "benevolent" and "civilising" rule in India.
------ ------
Schlik, “May 10, 2007 12:30
In answer to your questions, I offer you the following quote -
"How did 10,000 Englishmen rule more than 400 million Indians?
The English ruled Indians with Indian help. The most obvious example is in the fact that Indian and Nepalese troops were used to quell Indian uprisings. Thus Punjabi soldiers quelled movements in Bengal as Gurkha soldiers quelled uprisings in Punjab. After the 1857 Sepoy Mutiny, the colonial authorities used Indians from one region to patrol Indians from other regions."
(from Vikrum Sequeira's 'Indian nostalgia for the Raj; What's going on?'), as mentioned in my previous post.
P.S. Hitler was a famous admirer of the Indian Raj. He saw the British dominance as a good example of racial superiority and efficiency, which is exactly the same as the British saw it.
P.P.S. Incidentally, the US occupation of Iraq is using the Israeli-trained Kurdish militias, and Shia militant factions (which together make up the Iraqi army and police)
to combat the Sunni insurgency with a campaign of terror.
Divide and rule is the oldest occupation strategy on the planet. It was the reason for the campaign successes of both Caesar and Cortez, and I'm sure was used by others even before these two colonising generals came along and wreaked their havoc.”
------ -----------
Eccentrix, “I've noted a rather unpleasant piece of behaviour. Many people really think that the British Empire was established for the greater good and one particulary myopic poster suggests that India was run "for the good for all".
That's a load of crap. The Empire was based on Britain's ability to expand their area of influence by force in order to benefit Great Britain, first and foremost.
All talk of unpleasant local cultural practices are used as a smokescreen to distract attention from brutality meted out to people IN THEIR OWN COUNTRY by foreigners!!! If you manage to stretch the argument, you could even argue that saving women from burning themselves (as if that was the reason for colonising that part of the world) was worth all the lives lost in the rebellion and subsequent skirmishes. Rubbish.

The arrticle points to mistakes that were made in 1857 and frankly speaking (disregarding semantics), I can see the same mistakes being repeated 150 years later. Imposition of values on a foreign country, helping to turn country into a warzone, increased level of atrocities meted out by military of occupying force, rising alienation of local population and an unwavering delusional belief that if we carry on, everything will be alright eventually.

A wise man once said "Those who cannot remember history's mistakes are doomed to forever repeat them". Never were truer words spoken.”
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/2481371.stm
Friday, 15 November, 2002, 17:11 GMT
British Empire blamed for modern conflicts

Jack Straw said serious mistakes had been made

The UK Foreign Secretary, Jack Straw, has blamed Britain's imperial past for many of the modern political problems, including the Arab-Israeli conflict and the Kashmir dispute.
"A lot of the problems we are having to deal with now - I have to deal with now - are a consequence of our colonial past," he said.

The Balfour declaration... again, an interesting history for us, but not an honourable one

Jack Straw

In an interview with a British magazine, the New Statesman, Mr Straw spoke of quite serious mistakes made, especially during the last decades of the empire.

He said the Balfour Declaration of 1917 - in which Britain pledged support for a Jewish homeland in Palestine - and the contradictory assurances given to Palestinians, were not entirely honourable.

"The Balfour declaration and the contradictory assurances which were being given to Palestinians in private at the same time as they were being given to the Israelis - again, an interesting history for us, but not an honourable one," he said.

The odd lines for Iraq's borders were drawn by Brits

Jack Straw

Mr Straw acknowledged "some quite serious mistakes" in India and Pakistan, jewels of the British empire before their 1947 independence, as well as Britain's "less than glorious role" in Afghanistan.

'Odd' borders

Mr Straw blamed many territorial disputes on the illogical borders created by colonial powers.

He mentioned Iraq, the region which was governed by Britain under the mandate of the League of Nations after the defeat of the Ottoman Empire in World War I.

"The odd lines for Iraq's borders were drawn by Brits," he said.

And he said the British Government had been complacent about Kashmir at the time of Indian independence, when it quickly became the most contentious issue between India and Pakistan.

'Sensible statement'

This is not the first time Mr Straw has made controversial remarks about British history.

In the past he has blamed the English of oppressing the Scots, the Irish and the Welsh.


Mr Straw said British colonial past was less than honourable

Members of the main opposition Conservative Party accused Mr Straw of undermining British foreign policy, particularly in Zimbabwe, where President Robert Mugabe has justified his campaign against white farmers as a way of righting the wrongs of colonialism.

But Downing Street said Mr Straw's remarks were "a sensible statement of history".

Unusual

BBC's Diplomatic correspondent Barnaby Mason says that Mr Straw's critical remarks about British colonialism would be unsurprising coming from virtually anyone else.

Such views have been commonplace across the world and among left-wingers in Britain.

Our correspondent said 30 years ago, Mr Straw used to be an outspoken left winger himself.

Farmers Branch, anti-Federal


Farmers Branch's anti-immigration
Letter to Dallas Morning News, 7:00 AM, May 13

I am concerned about passing of the Farmers Branch Immigration Laws. I am against illegal immigration, but I am not in favor of City States, this is a dangerous precedent, is the next thing to have their own Military? Is Farmer's Branch representative of a typical American City or is it an anomaly? The neo-cons are getting thrown out for their extreme positions every where, this is jolting news.

I do hope in the interest of peaceful co-existence in local communities, we need to fight this out. Let there not be any vigilantism. It is a bad stain on our Metroplex. Let the immigration be handled by the Federal Government and l I know that a majority of the Americans would not go for it, it is transgression of Federal government. Where are our congressman on this issue?

-------------------------
A Message Unread: Farmers Branch vote is a pointless sideshow

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/dn/opinion/editorials/stories/DN-FB_07edi.ART.State.Edition1.42d90da.html

06:55 AM CDT on Monday, May 7, 2007

Of all the wasted energy put into the Farmers Branch immigration debate, perhaps none is misspent more than in the argument over legal fees.

Also Online
Campaign contributions database

Elections 2007: Read the latest stories, see candidate video statements, review DMN recommendations and more.

Candidate Quiz: Don't know which local candidates to vote for on May 12? Check out their positions on key issues.

Whether it's one side's "hundreds of thousands" or the other side's "hundreds of thousands," it will be hundreds of thousands more than any other city in North Texas, because Farmers Branch stands alone in pursuing a ban on renting to illegal immigrants.

Legal costs for lawsuits are just the start. Enforcing this pointless law wouldn't be cheap, if even possible. And, of course, there is the opportunity cost. What could Farmers Branch do with the time and energy its staff and citizens are pouring into the immigration debate?

And all of this for what?

Well, say supporters, to send a message! To lead the charge! As if Congress needs a message from Farmers Branch, Texas, to realize that we have a national immigration mess. Besides, what happens if you charge into battle and no one follows? You gain battle wounds for nothing.

Perhaps that's why the overwhelming majority of people seeking city council seats across North Texas have no intention of following Farmers Branch up this hill. Of the 91 candidates who directly answered our immigration question on our Candidate Quiz, only four from outside Farmers Branch said they would like to see their city take on this federal issue.

So no matter what happens to Ordinance 2903 at the polls Saturday in Farmers Branch, rest assured that pretty close to every other local leader understands that immigration is a federal problem that should be resolved at the federal level, by an elected Congress.

They just aren't as loud as those who look in the wrong places for unworkable, feel-good answers.

Dallas Elections - 2007

Dallas/ Fort Worth Elections -2007
The winners, loosers and concerns.


Here is a complete run down of the May 12, Dallas/ Fort Worth City and School elections followed by my notes;

I am concerned about passing of the Farmers Branch Immigration Laws. I am against illegal immigration, but I am not in favor of City States, this is a dangerous precedent, is the next thing their own Military? Is Farmer's Branch representative of a typical American City or is it an anamoly? The neo-cons are getting thrown out for their extreme positions every where, this is jolting news. I do hope in the interest of co-existence in local communities, we need to fight this out. Let the immigration be handled by the Federal Government. I know that a majority of the Americans would not go for it.

The passing of bond in Allen bodes well for the improvements and progress for the city.

Dallas News had favored Tom Leppert and now he is in the run off. He seems like a good choice for the City.

Glad to see Mayor Salgel in Richardson is unopposed and hope Bob Townsend makes it. He is active in the communities and makes time to be with his people.

Here is the index followed by the columns from Dallas Morning News.

Index:

1. Farmers Branch Immigration Law wins
2. Dallas Mayoral Election: Leppert, Oakley headed for runoff
3. FB mayor: No real winners in this vote
4. Dallas runoff gives voters a choice of two very different candidates
5. Runoffs are set in Garland, Richardson races
6. $77.8 million bond issue passes in Allen
7. County elections Web sites
8. Carrollton Farmers Branch News
9. Voters fired up in Farmers Branch

----------------- ---------------
FB immigration law wins easily
http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/news/politics/local/stories/051307dnmetfarmersbranch.621241fe.html
02:35 AM CDT on Sunday, May 13, 2007
By STEPHANIE SANDOVAL / The Dallas Morning News
ssandoval@dallasnews.com

Also Online
DiscussLive: Stephanie Sandoval answers your questions on Ordinance 2903 on Monday at 1 p.m. Send early questions
Farmers Branch voters' overwhelming embrace of a law to drive out illegal immigrants – which backers celebrated Saturday as "nothing but positive" – may lead to similar measures across North Texas and the nation, analysts say.
The nation's first vote on an ordinance targeting illegal immigrants by barring them from renting apartments highlighted a resentment of the federal government's failure to secure the nation's borders – and a desire to do something about it at the local level, said City Council member Tim O'Hare, who was the driving force behind the ordinance.
"They are saying loud and clear they want change in Farmers Branch," he said. "People recognize we have a problem, and they are proud we stood up. This is nothing but positive results for Farmers Branch."

Mr. O'Hare's message that illegal immigrants are having a negative impact on neighborhoods, crime, property values and schools may soon be heard in other cities.

"I'd be shocked if I didn't see other cities follow suit," he said. "I've been contacted by representatives from other cities. Any city that wants to protect their town, give me a call, and let us work together."

Opponents of the ordinance said they will try to stop the ordinance in the courts, and despite their defeat, they say they will have an impact on the city in the future.
"Regardless of the results, this is only the beginning," said Ana Reyes. "The community outreach we're doing is going to empower the Hispanic community [to become citizens]. I want them to feel a sense of involvement in the city."

Matthew Wilson, a political science professor at Southern Methodist University, said the implications of the Farmers Branch election may be felt more in cities elsewhere.
"Farmers Branch is a closed-in suburb of a major American city," Mr. Wilson said. "This is not some sort of remote, rural outpost. Farmers Branch is a pretty mainstream place, and if there is this level of anger about the immigration situation there, then what that suggests is there's probably a lot more of this kind of anger around the country."
And politicians may look to capitalize on the issue by taking similar tough local stances on illegal immigrants, he said.

Irving City Council candidate Tom Spink, who ran on an anti-illegal-immigrant platform, easily won election Saturday over longtime incumbent James Dickens.
And look for more anti-illegal-immigrant measures in Farmers Branch with the election Saturday of two new pro-ordinance council members, David Koch and Tim Scott. The City Council now has a solid majority committed to more ordinances targeting illegal immigrants. Both Mr. Koch and Mr. Scott have said they favor expanding the ban on renting apartments to illegal immigrants to all rental properties in the city and cracking down on businesses that hire illegal immigrants.

But with two lawsuits pending against the city, it could be years before the ordinance takes effect. Attorneys in those lawsuits are expected to immediately file requests from the courts for injunctions to stop the city from implementing the law on May 22, as planned.
Though other cities over the last year or so have adopted similar apartment ordinances, Farmers Branch is the first in Texas to do so, and the first nationwide to put the issue to a city vote.

The ordinance is modeled largely after one adopted by Hazleton, Pa., the first city to adopt a rental ban on illegal immigrants. That city also was sued. The case went to trial in the spring, but the judge has not issued a decision yet.

"You have cities all across the country responding to constituent demands," said Kris Kobach, a law professor at the University of Missouri-Kansas City. He also is a constitutional law and immigration expert who defended Hazleton in court and helped Farmers Branch craft the ordinance that went to voters.

"These ordinances have proven very popular among city councils," Mr. Kobach said. "This shows the city councils are accurately responding to public opinion. ... A referendum is essentially a perfect public opinion survey because you're questioning the entire electorate."
One political analyst said that the impact might not be as great as it would have been several months ago.

Illegal immigration "is still a very live issue, but my sense is it doesn't have the forward momentum it had in the latter half of 2006, because it was then a signature issue of the Republican Party," Cal Jillson, also a political science professor at SMU, said last week.
A spokesman for Let the Voters Decide, a group that opposed the ordinance, also said the issue may not spread to other cities.

"We're disappointed in the result, but I think the campaign was successful in that it was able to elevate the level of debate about this ordinance and prove the many ways this ordinance is costly and ill-advised," said the spokesman, Travis Carter. "Because of our campaign, there isn't a community or city in North Texas that would think to support an ordinance like this."
The fiery debate drew charges of racism and accusations of voter intimidation and dissemination of wrong or misleading information on both sides both since last fall. Mayor Bob Phelps' house was vandalized twice, including once last week immediately after he announced his opposition to the ordinance.

It also thrust Mr. O'Hare, a native of the city, and Farmers Branch into the national spotlight. Anticipating the large turnout, Dallas County set up seven voting locations in the city for Saturday. Usually, the city of 28,500 has only one polling place. In the end, about 43 percent of 14,060 registered voters turned out and approved the referendum by a more than 2-to-1 margin.

Ordinance 2903 would require apartment management to obtain proof of citizenship or legal immigration status before entering into or renewing leases or rental agreements.
The only exception to the ban would be that mixed-status families could stay if they were already living in the apartment, the spouse or head of household is a citizen or here legally, and the household includes the head of household and spouse and their minor children or parents.

Staff writers Eric Aasen, Stella M. Chavez and Jay Parsons contributed to this report.
------------ ------------

Dallas Mayoral Election: Leppert, Oakley headed for runoff

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/news/politics/local/stories/051307dnmetdallasmayor.62241469.html
12:16 AM CDT
12:23 AM CDT on Sunday, May 13, 2007
From Staff Reports
And then there were two.
Former construction company executive Tom Leppert and District 3 City Council member Ed Oakley took the top spots in the crowded Dallas mayoral election Saturday. Mr. Leppert drew 27.1 percent of the votes and Mr. Oakley garnered 20.7 percent.
Also Online
Leppert, Oakley headed for runoff
Analysis: Runoff a study in contrasts
FB immigration law wins big
Jacquielynn Floyd: FB mayor says no real winners in this vote
Dallas council races in runoff
Voters OK Bush library land sale
Incumbents keep DISD seats
Tax break approved for elderly
Mostly trouble-free day
Runoffs are set in Garland, Richardson races
Collin County roundup
S. Dallas County roundup
Rockwall/Rowlett roundup
Interactive map: Results by precinct
Tell us: Your candidate lost, so who gets your vote now?
None of the 11 candidates seeking to replace Laura Miller captured a majority of the votes, and the two leaders now head to a June 16 runoff.
Mr. Leppert appeared to have drawn strong support across North Dallas, while Mr. Oakley’s supporters mostly were in West Dallas, with a few scattered precincts across the south.
Mayor Pro Tem Don Hill had 13.9 percent and was followed closely by banker Max Wells who had 12.2 percent.
This has been the most expensive mayoral race in Dallas history, with more candidates than anyone can remember.
The candidates together have spent more than $4.5 million by Election Day. That’s more than any previous campaign, and it doesn’t include the money runoff candidates will spend.
Mr. Leppert led his opponents both in fundraising and in campaign expenditures. And his well-oiled campaign also attracted endorsements from many members of Dallas business and political elite.
But other candidates also have amassed huge war chests and gathered key endorsements. Mr. Oakley, taking advantage of a high-profile council service, touted southern Dallas credentials and reached out to North Dallas.
Another deep-pocketed candidate, Mr. Wells, the race’s oldest candidate, connected his face with past political victories. Mr. Hill was hoping to ride his widespread support in the south into a runoff. His entanglement in a two-year-old FBI investigation into corruption at City Hall has dogged his campaign and crippled his fund-raising efforts.
Current council member Gary Griffith was heavily courting Republican voters, and retired airline executive Sam Coats was making similar appeals to Democrats. Lawyer Darrell Jordan has made the run for mayor before and hoped to draw support from the vote-rich north.
Staff writer Dave Levinthal contributed to this report.
--- ---
FB mayor: No real winners in this vote

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/dn/localnews/columnists/jfloyd/stories/DN-floyd_13met.State.Edition1.3d5c21f.html
01:07 AM CDT on Sunday, May 13, 2007
jfloyd@dallasnews.com
FARMERS BRANCH – Election night used to be a lot of fun for Bob Phelps.
Also Online
FB immigration ordinance approved by landslide
As a popular, longtime mayor who ran unopposed for the last three of his four terms, he would spend the evening at City Hall announcing the returns.
If there were any hot races, this was the night for gracious gestures and all-is-forgiven displays of community solidarity. Mr. Phelps hasn't missed election night since 1986, when he was appointed to the town zoning board.
Until this year.
This year, Mr. Phelps and his wife, Dee, left town.
With what seemed like the whole nation watching and the town seething with tension, city leaders decided to let the results come directly from the county.
Besides, federal agents, sent to investigate the second act of vandalism at the mayor's house since the furor over illegal immigrants erupted, candidly told the Phelpses that out of town was perhaps the best place for them to be.
"These last few months have been the worst time – I don't know, maybe of my life," Mr. Phelps said a few nights ago as we sat around the kitchen table. "I've tried to do what's right. It's so disappointing."
"Disappointing" is awfully mild language when you consider the berserk, spit-flecked hysteria that Ordinance 2903 has engendered at the extremes of both sides.
Those who have tried to keep the debate at a practical level – the cost, enforcement issues, legal risks – have been drowned out for months by overwrought or, worse, calculatedly manipulative partisans. It turned into an all-out war between good and evil, right and wrong.
And a miserable, no-win dilemma for the mayor.
"I'm not in favor of anything illegal," he said. "I'm certainly not in favor of illegal immigration."
But in Farmers Branch, opposition to 2903 has been equated to precisely that: "support" for unchecked, uncontrolled immigration; timid surrender of "American" language, values and culture.
Mr. Phelps and a handful of attorneys and staff members seem to be the only people in town who realized that passing this ordinance could – and probably will – cost a king's ransom in legal fees.
After campaigning and leading for two decades as a fiscal conservative, he was appalled at the risk.
The town has long prided itself on a "pay-as-you-go" policy. New building projects are paid for in full – Farmers Branch hasn't had to float a bond proposal in 20 years.
"We're already spending hundreds of thousands of dollars on attorney's fees," he said, defending against two lawsuits filed since the council first adopted anti-illegal immigrant measures a few months ago.
A few more years of vigorous litigation – after Saturday's vote, a virtual guarantee – will eat through the city's financial reserves like cows through a cornfield, he said.
So, four days before the election, Mr. Phelps went public with what he had been saying privately for months: 2903 would be terrible for Farmers Branch.
"I'm getting hate mail," he said unhappily, as Mrs. Phelps leafed through a pile of printouts, reading from a few e-mails:
"You are an embarrassment to your city – please resign." "You are a pathetic excuse for a leader." "You are a traitor."
"I worry about him," Mrs. Phelps confided. "He's been under so much stress. People turned on him so fast."
With a year left on his term, Mr. Phelps says he's not planning to quit, and he's certainly not considering relocation.
"We've been in Farmers Branch since 1955," he said. "Our friends are here."
With infinite sadness, he added: "I guess our enemies are here, too."
--- ---

Dallas runoff gives voters a choice of two very different candidates

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/news/politics/local/stories/DN-dalanalysis_13met.State.Edition1.3d69eca.html
01:29 AM CDT on Sunday, May 13, 2007
By GROMER JEFFERS JR. / The Dallas Morning News
gjeffers@dallasnews.com
ANALYSIS
Dallas mayoral candidates Tom Leppert and Ed Oakley bring contrasting styles and campaigns to the June 16 runoff.
How they made the runoff
Tom Leppert:
•Employed massive campaign resources and a hefty list of endorsements to overwhelm most of his competitors.
•Hired high-dollar consultants to produce critical TV ads and mailers for a consistent, almost relentless message.
•Cast himself as a business-savvy City Hall outsider with fresh ideas. Crushed his rivals in North Dallas, who all finished far off the pace.
Ed Oakley:
•Blended his strong support in north Oak Cliff, Oak Lawn and parts of southern Dallas with just enough votes from elsewhere.
•Had the best grass-roots campaign. Avoided costly TV commercials in favor of billboards and mailers. His plan to tear down thousands of crime-plagued apartment units in North Dallas resonated with voters.
How they match up
It will be the veteran City Hall insider against the newcomer pushed by the city's business elite.
•Mr. Leppert poured massive resources into the southern sector, where he finished surprisingly strong. He'll sharpen his focus in North Dallas, but the south will be the site of key battles.
•Mr. Leppert is expected to continue to talk about "big ideas" instead of nuts-and-bolts issues like filling potholes.
•Mr. Oakley is trying to become what he calls the first mayor from the southern sector.
•Mr. Oakley continues to bring with him a strong Oak Cliff base. He's popular with neighborhood activists and the city's gay political machine.
•Mr. Oakley will continue to use his crusade against crime-ridden apartment buildings to gain steam in North Dallas, where Mr. Leppert holds the advantage.
Political appeals
Both candidates will work hard to appeal to black voters, many of them supporters of council member Don Hill.
With Mr. Hill out of the race, Mr. Oakley will lay claim to the entire south.
Radio talk show host-turned-consultant Willis Johnson effectively chipped away at Mr. Hill's stronghold in Oak Cliff, giving Mr. Leppert a significant beachhead.
Despite the attention to the southern sector by numerous candidates, mayoral races are almost always won in North Dallas.
Each will be working to woo his opponent's supporters.
Early friction
Mr. Leppert has cast himself as a man with the big picture. He'll try to minimize Mr. Oakley as merely a council member without a broad vision.
It's not Mr. Leppert's style to meet his opponent head-on, but his future ads and campaign mailers will stress a need for new leadership.
Mr. Oakley has often been irked by Mr. Leppert's contention that City Hall is on the wrong path.
He'll portray Mr. Leppert as an outsider with little knowledge about how City Hall works.
Mr. Oakley also recognizes the importance of the south, where he has told residents to ignore neighbors who support North Dallas candidates.
What happened to the others?
•Former council member Max Wells spent at least $800,000 of his own money on his campaign. But his poor showing suggests he failed to get traction in key parts of North Dallas.
•Council member Gary Griffith's effort to appeal to Republicans and former airlines executive Sam Coats' tactic to appeal to Democrats ultimately didn't work.
Mr. Griffith may have turned off Democratic supporters in his own Lakewood district and in the southern sector by trotting out the likes of Republican U.S. Rep. Pete Sessions and other members of the GOP.
And most of the Democrats whom Mr. Coats craved probably wound up with Mr. Oakley and Mr. Hill.
•Darrell Jordan, an early candidate for mayor, failed to build on his early support in North Dallas, or on his unsuccessful 1995 campaign against Ron Kirk.

--- ---
Runoffs are set in Garland, Richardson races

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/news/politics/local/stories/DN-dalcowrap_13met.State.Edition1.3d7a914.html

Dallas County: Many suburban offices won by incumbents
01:14 AM CDT on Sunday, May 13, 2007
By WENDY HUNDLEY and RICHARD ABSHIRE / The Dallas Morning News
Runoffs will have to decide the winners of races in Garland and Richardson. Irving will have an all-white school board. Suburban voters returned incumbents to their positions in a number of races.
Here's a wrap-up of key races:
Garland mayor, council
In the Garland mayor's race, former assistant city manager Ron Jones and credit union vice president Lee Alewine are headed for a June 16 runoff, finishing first and second respectively in a three-way race.
Mr. Jones was Garland's first black assistant city manager.
If he wins the runoff, he will be the city's first black mayor.
In City Council District 6, incumbent Barbara Chick easily defeated challenger Marcus Reed for the second time.
In a battle of political newcomers, Rick Williams, recently retired from the Social Security Administration, won over retail planner Scott LeMay in District 7.
Preston Edwards ran unopposed in District 3, as did Darren Lathen in District 8.
Richardson City Council
Challenger Bill Denton and incumbent Bob Townsend were running a tight race for Place 1. With all precincts reporting, Mr. Townsend led Mr. Denton.
In another very close race, Place 7 challenger Dennis Stewart had a slight lead over incumbent John Sweeden.
It's the second time these two have faced off in a race for a City Council seat.
Mr. Sweeden edged out Mr. Stewart in 2005.
But incumbents were sailing to easy victories in other races.
Rhea Allison was headed to his second term in his Place 2 seat, leading by a wide margin over Kevin Cozort.
In Place 3, incumbent John Murphy held a firm lead over opponent Darrell Day.
In the race for Place 6, Steve Mitchell, who was elected in 2005, prevailed over Matthew Moseley.
Mayor Gary Slagel had no opponent for his Place 4 seat.
In the five-way race for Place 5, a runoff was brewing between George McKearin and Pris Hayes.
Irving City Council
In the race for Place 1, challenger Thomas D. Spink held a strong lead over incumbent James Dickens.
In the three-way race for Place 5, Rose Cannaday was headed to fill the unexpired term of her husband, Lowell Cannaday, who stepped down to run for Dallas County sheriff.
Place 2 incumbent Beth Van Duyne and Place 7 incumbent Sam Smith faced no opposition.
Irving ISD
In the race for Place 5, incumbent Nita Patrick outdistanced Patricia J. Kilmer.
Incumbent Jerry Christian ran unopposed in Place 6.
In the three-way race for Place 7, Ronda Huffstetler had a decisive lead over her two challengers, Gloria Agyemang and Adrian Tyrone "A.D." Jenkins.
Ms. Huffstetler is white. Her challengers are black.
Ms. Huffstetler's victory means an all-white school board for the minority-majority district.
Mesquite ISD
Incumbent Mesquite school board member Rita Crump won re-election, dashing challenger Barry Walker's hopes.
Both candidates supported a $180 million school bond program that included money for a new elementary school in south Mesquite. The bond program passed.
Carrollton-
Farmers Branch ISD
The third time was the charm for attorney Frank Shor, 55, who won a seat on the school board after losing two previous bids. He defeated retired Highland Park school administrator Rodney Pirtle, 72.
whundley@dallasnews.com
rabshire@dallasnews.com
------- -----------
$77.8 million bond issue passes in Allen

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/news/politics/local/stories/DN-collinwrap_13met.State.Edition1.3d89ae0.html

Collin County: Sedlacek, Goss, Webb, Poe win seats; Frisco runoff set
01:09 AM CDT on Sunday, May 13, 2007
By JAKE BATSELL / The Dallas Morning News
jbatsell@dallasnews.com
Allen voters approved spending $77.8 million for a bond package that will improve streets, parks and public safety facilities, but a measure to spend $1.4 million on public

ALLEN BOND ELECTION
Allen residents approved all six bond propositions. The largest amount, $27.2 million, is for street improvements. The next-largest, $17.2 million, is for park improvements.
Voters were less certain about $1.4 million to implement a public art master plan, approving it by only a slim margin even though there was no organized opposition.
ALLEN CITY COUNCIL AND SCHOOL BOARD
Winners: Robin Sedlacek and Lois Lindsey
Accountant Robin Sedlacek cruised to a decisive victory over educator and executive Phillip Jenkins in the City Council Place 4 race.
Retired teacher Lois Lindsey defeated sales manager Scott Jergensen for the Place 4 school board seat.
FRISCO CITY COUNCIL
Runoff contenders: Jeff Cheney, Fred Pascarelli, David Prince, Chris Moss
Jeff Cheney, a 32-year-old real estate agent, and Fred Pascarelli, a 43-year-old software developer, will compete in a runoff election for the Place 2 council seat.
David Prince, a 57-year-old accountant, and Chris Moss, a 36-year-old risk management consultant, will square off for the Place 4 council seat.
--------- -------------

County elections Web sites

04:28 PM CDT on Friday, May 11, 2007
Dallas County elections site : http://www.dalcoelections.org/
Collin County elections site : http://www.co.collin.tx.us/elections/index.jsp
Denton County elections site : http://elections.dentoncounty.com/go.asp?Dept=82
Tarrant County elections site : http://www.tarrantcounty.com/eVote/site/default.asp
Rockwall County elections site : http://www.rockwallcountytexas.com/ea.htm
----------------- -----------------

Carrollton /Farmers Branch

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/news/city/carrollton/vitindex.html
05/13/2007

Attorneys: Prepare for court fight
FARMERS BRANCH – The first order of business for attorneys Marisol Perez and Bill Brewer this week is to block implementation of an ordinance that would crack down on apartment owners who rent to most illegal immigrants.
05/12/2007
FB immigration law wins easily
Voters in Farmers Branch strongly favored an ordinance that would make the city the first in the nation to prohibit landlords from renting apartments to most illegal immigrants.
AREA BRIEFS
Voters fired up in Farmers Branch
Say what you will about the illegal-immigrant measure on the ballot, it at least has given democracy a sorely needed shot in the arm.
McKamy Elementary presents: 'Broadway at Briargrove'
The glamour and glitter of Broadway come to the Carrollton-Farmers Branch school district in a pint-size version of musical magic when the McKamy Elementary School choir performs two shows next week.
SCHOOL BRIEFS
C-FB school district
NORTHWEST DALLAS HOME SALES
This list of selected home sales in Carrollton, Dallas and Farmers Branch was compiled by MasterFiles Inc. from county deed records. The amount listed is the mortgage, not the total price. In each ZIP code, sales are organized alphabetically by street.
GOOD KID
CONGRATULATIONS
COMMUNITY CALENDAR
MOTHER'S DAY CONCERT : The A. W. Perry Museum presents a free Mother's Day concert at 6 p.m. Sunday. Guests should bring blankets or lawn chairs. Free ice cream and lemonade will be provided. The event includes a picnic basket contest with registration starting at 5:15 p.m. The museum is at 1509 N. Perry Road. Call 972-466-6380.
POLICE BLOTTER
The police blotter summarizes selected crimes reported in Carrollton through Sunday and is organized alphabetically by street, with the reported time.
05/11/2007
FB rivals step up efforts

JIM MAHONEY/DMN
Signs showing support of or opposition to Ordinance 2903 are seen throughout Farmers Branch.
As the campaigns for and against an ordinance targeting illegal immigrants in Farmers Branch enter the final two days, both sides intensified their efforts to appeal for votes in what already is a record turnout for the city.

Feds to monitor FB election
The Justice Department will send federal monitors to observe the controversial Farmers Branch election on a measure that would ban apartments from renting to most illegal immigrants.
FBI may investigate attack
The FBI is conducting what it calls a preliminary investigation into an act of vandalism against the home of Farmers Branch Mayor Bob Phelps this week.
05/10/2007
Study: Rental ban bad for FB

JIM MAHONEY/DMN
Signs showing support of or opposition to Ordinance 2903 are seen throughout Farmers Branch.
Crime rates are down, unemployment is low, business buzzes because of prime footage near major arteries and interstates. But marketing of the city's pluses could go bust because of those trying to rid Farmers Branch of illegal immigrants, according to a study paid for by a group fighting an anti-illegal immigrant ordinance in the city.

05/09/2007
FB mayor's window hit by vandal
A vandal threw a rock and broke a rear window of Farmers Branch Mayor Bob Phelps' home late Tuesday or early Wednesday. Mr. Phelps and his wife, Dee, were home at the time, but neither heard anything, city spokesman Tom Bryson said.
Early voting in FB breaks 14-year record
Farmers Branch voters – fired up over a divisive and controversial ordinance aimed at illegal immigrants – hit the polls in record numbers during early voting that ended Tuesday.
05/08/2007
FB mayor rejects ordinance in letter
Farmers Branch Mayor Bob Phelps has come out strongly against a controversial proposed anti-illegal immigrant ordinance on Saturday's ballot in a letter that went out to voters Tuesday.
Friends agree to disagree in FB


---------------------- ----------------
Voters fired up in Farmers Branch

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/dn/localnews/columnists/jragland/stories/DN-ragland_12met.ART0.North.Edition1.434a6b4.html
10:04 AM CDT on Saturday, May 12, 2007
The early vote is in, and the clear-cut winner is ... Farmers Branch.
Proving once again that there's nothing like an incendiary issue to get the electorate off the couch.
In Dallas, we've got a crowded double-digit field of candidates running for mayor. Combined, they've spent millions of bucks on high-dollar consultants and slick media ads to separate from the pack. They've rehearsed their campaign speeches so often that they can recite them in their sleep.
And how are voters reacting?
With a yawn as wide as the Trinity River.
Roughly 25,000 Dallas voters bothered to cast early ballots, underscoring political pundits' predictions of a paltry turnout in the low teens.
"Not much excitement is going on in Dallas," said Dallas County Elections Administrator Bruce Sherbet. "It's just average, middle-of-the-road. I think our turnout is going to be about 13 percent."
Translation: ho-hum. Wake us up for the runoff election in June.
No one is sleeping in Farmers Branch. Say what you will about the illegal-immigrant measure on the ballot, it at least has given democracy a sorely needed shot in the arm.
"I'm not seeing anything but Farmers Branch going crazy," Mr. Sherbet said. "It's just amazing what's going on out there."
Case in point. The highest previous turnout for a municipal election in Farmers Branch was about 3,200. The electorate's already broken that record. More than 3,500 voters cast early ballots.
And Mr. Sherbet projects that Farmers Branch will generate election day votes like never before.
"They'll probably end up with a 50 percent turnout in Farmers Branch," he said, adding that North Texas jurisdictions seldom, if ever, reach that level of participation for a local election.
"There will be nothing for the city to compare it to. And they may not ever see these numbers again."
Question: Is it too late to get our own flamethrower, Laura Miller, on the mayoral ballot?
"There is something about that Laura Miller love-hate thing," Mr. Sherbet acknowledged.
Without a real fireball personality or issue in the race, Dallas voters have just tuned out.
Or so it appears.
The idealist in me is still hoping that registered voters will wake up this morning, take a cue from Farmers Branch residents and march to the polls ...
In Dallas.
I know that's a long shot. We have a better chance of the Mavs beating Golden State in seven.
But it's also a shame that voters seem to care so little, especially when the city has produced the largest number of mayoral candidates ever.
These aren't fringe candidates, by and large. Most of them are straight-laced, sober-headed and civic-minded. They are a thoughtful and respectable bunch with good ideas about how to move the city forward. They've paid their dues.
Problem is, they're also b-o-r-i-n-g.
Which is not to say that none of them has a sense of humor or can't occasionally crack a clever quip or deliver a good line. If you went to a forum or two, you know what I mean. Or if you've managed to get one-on-one time with the candidates, which, unfortunately, only a privileged few ever get a chance to do in big-city politics.
So one glaring problem was that the serious candidates were too busy trying to look, well, you know, mayoral.
And most voters have been looking the other way, seemingly unaffected by the candidates' billboards, fliers, automated phone calls and campaign commercial plugs.
Voters like grit and tension. They want to understand what the stakes are, to see someone waving fingers and pounding the podiums with their fists.
They want clear choices.
They're getting that in Farmers Branch, in the form of an ordinance that would ban landlords from renting to most illegal immigrants.
In Dallas, voters are getting a chance to pick one of multiple mayoral candidates, several of whom have solid credentials and worthy ideas, and none of whom is expected to win outright.
The results: Farmers Branch gets U.S. Justice Department officials on hand to observe an election that's being talked about nationally and is attracting record voters.
And Dallas gets a costly dud.

Saturday, May 12, 2007

Mickey Mouse & Hamas TV

Mickey & Hamas TV
Mike Ghouse, May 12, 2007

Using Mickey Mouse to propogate hate among Children is wrong, dead wrong.
In behalf of the World Muslim Congress, we condemn the hate mongering that is contained in the TV program.

In the interest of the well being of Children, and inthe interest of keeping the peace prospects alive, we urge the Hamas Leadership to modify the show to preach peace. We urge the Arab leadership to take this up with the Hamas management and ask them to re-do the show without any hate towards America, Israel or any one. No child should be brainwashed with hate as it is poisonous to the keep the venom in one's heart, and also it is damaging to their future, and is an hindrance to the spirit of co-operation. We also urge the Government of Israel to listen to her people and observe the international law and stop the settlements.

When there is conflict, people on both sides exaggerate and lie, in this case we do not know how wide the audience is and how popular the show is. However, we do know that MEMRI TV puts out a lot of propoganda in the name of research and they are committed to malign the parties they are determined to do. I don't know if an equal amount of hate is spewed out of Israel, if some one has the information, I would welcome it, nothing beats being fair and just.

It is in humanity's intrest to be fair and just.

Mike Ghouse

Special Dispatch— Palestinian Authority / Jihad & Terrorism
May 14, 2007, No. 1584

Hamas TV Insists on Continuing Inciting Children TV Show

To view this Special Dispatch in HTML, visit:
http://www.memri.org/bin/opener_latest.cgi?ID=SD158407

The following are excerpts from a report on the Al-Aqsa TV children's show "The Pioneers of Tomorrow," with the addition of excerpts from the May 11, 2007 show.

To view this clip, go to http://www.memritv.org/search.asp?ACT=S9&P1=1446

Reporter:

The Al-Aqsa Satellite TV Channel denounced the vicious campaign that is being waged against it, and against its children’s show, "The Pioneers of Tomorrow," which airs every Friday. [Al-Aqsa TV] emphasized its noble message, which aims to produce a believing generation that will bear the noble values and strive to spread goodness and justice in Palestine and the world. Al-Aqsa TV stressed to its viewers that the airing of the show would continue, and announced that the show airs at 4 p.m. Occupied Jerusalem Time every Friday. Al-Aqsa TV talked over the phone with Fathi Hammad, director of the Al-Aqsa media network.

Al-Aqsa Media Network Director Fathi Hamad: The vicious [campaign] that is being waged by the enemies, and especially the Zionist enemy and the American imperialism, is not new. It comes in the framework of the vicious campaign against our Palestinian people, as an addition to the siege placed on our people. Therefore, we are not surprised by this. They want the Palestinian people to renounce its Islamic religion and belief. In response, we say that whenever our Palestinian people resorted to its religion, Allah supported it. Therefore, we will not renounce our faith and our belief, and we will move forward for the sake of Allah. We are holding to this religion because it is the secret of our victory. They try, as much as they can… Not just by waging their attack on the religion in this context, in order to prevent the Islamic upbringing of the Palestinian children, but they also want this people to renounce all its Islamic foundations. They are the ones who called to remove the jihad verses that appear in the Palestinian school curricula. Therefore, we cannot accept this.

From “The Pioneers of Tomorrow” show:

Hazem: "Not just the Palestinian child, but also the Iraqi child, as you can see. They kill and slaughter the children and the women. Whoever followed the news yesterday could see the fetus and its mother… I'm sure you saw that, Saraa."

Saraa: "Yes, this was very moving."

Hazem: "They are doing it in Iraq, in Afghanistan, and in Palestine, and a while ago they were doing it in Lebanon. The situation is very difficult. Nevertheless, Hadil, Allah willing, the day Islam rules the world, there will be justice, love, and peace, and all the people will love one another. That is history."

Farfour, a Mickey Mouse character in a tuxedo: "Hazem…"

Hazem: "Yes, my friend… "

Farfour: "Who is this Islam – is it my uncle on my father’s side or on my mother’s side?"

Hazem: "Islam is our religion, in which there is love, goodness, and peace."